Consumer Alert: Do cramped airplanes pose a safety risk?

Do cramped commercial airplanes pose a safety risk? Some experts seem to think so.

News 12 Staff

Oct 11, 2019, 9:48 PM

Updated 1,669 days ago

Share:

Anyone who has flown on a commercial airline recently will know that airplanes seem to be getting more crowded as airlines shrink seats and aisle space to fit in more passengers.
But do those cramped conditions pose a safety risk? Some experts say that it does.
“The statistics are pretty clear that most fatalities occur not because of impact on crash landings but because people cannot get out quickly enough,” says Paul Hudson with the nonprofit group Flyers Rights, a group that is calling on the government to regulate the size of airline seats.
“There’s a rule called the 90-second rule that says everyone has to be able to get out in that amount of time. There’s a big question whether that’s possible with shrinking seats and larger passengers,” Hudson says.
The Federal Aviation Administration appears to be taking notice. The agency will run tests next month to see if passengers can evacuate an airplane fast enough to meet the safety standards.
The study will simulate a real plane crash and the crew will have 90 seconds to get everyone off. But each time, half of the exits will be locked and the crew will not know which ones those are. The passengers will be volunteers of all ages, including children, senior citizens and possibly those with service animals.
But Flyers Rights says that it isn’t convinced that the FAA will take the testing seriously.
“Although I’m on the committee that’s studying the evacuation, I just found out about it and the details have been kept secret,” says Hudson.
Hudson’s group is also calling on the FAA to release the full test results and not just a summary.


More from News 12
1:35
Child struck by vehicle in Spring Valley, 5th incident in 2024

Child struck by vehicle in Spring Valley, 5th incident in 2024

1:50
Sunny skies, comfortable conditions today before rain returns Wednesday

Sunny skies, comfortable conditions today before rain returns Wednesday

0:39
 ‘Melanie’s Law’ passes state Senate, heads for final approval

‘Melanie’s Law’ passes state Senate, heads for final approval

0:29
Attorney General James sues local clinics for abortion-reversal claims

Attorney General James sues local clinics for abortion-reversal claims

0:20
East Ramapo parents rally for school reform

East Ramapo parents rally for school reform

0:50
Headlines: Brewster police mourn death of officer, Newburgh man sentenced for rape, Westchester man arrested for larceny

Headlines: Brewster police mourn death of officer, Newburgh man sentenced for rape, Westchester man arrested for larceny

0:29
Dutchess County Sheriff's Office rescues 90 cats living in disarray

Dutchess County Sheriff's Office rescues 90 cats living in disarray

1:42
24-year-old double organ transplant recipient hosts blood drive in Pomona

24-year-old double organ transplant recipient hosts blood drive in Pomona

1:36
‘Very best’ of PD: City of Newburgh promotes longtime lieutenant to chief

‘Very best’ of PD: City of Newburgh promotes longtime lieutenant to chief

1:49
SUNY Purchase faculty and students want disciplinary action against protesters dropped

SUNY Purchase faculty and students want disciplinary action against protesters dropped

0:50
Orange County cracks down on drivers who illegally pass school buses with cameras

Orange County cracks down on drivers who illegally pass school buses with cameras

1:56
Ceremony held to mark Holocaust Remembrance Day in White Plains

Ceremony held to mark Holocaust Remembrance Day in White Plains

1:01
Tuckahoe Village Board hears Ward House appeal

Tuckahoe Village Board hears Ward House appeal

0:23
State police work to ID body that washed ashore in Poughkeepsie

State police work to ID body that washed ashore in Poughkeepsie

0:35
Rockland DA: 23-year-old man indicted in New City driveway stabbing

Rockland DA: 23-year-old man indicted in New City driveway stabbing

1:11
SUNY Purchase creates ‘protest zone’ following encampment break up by police

SUNY Purchase creates ‘protest zone’ following encampment break up by police

0:45
Hudson River Clean Up Day celebrates 13th year

Hudson River Clean Up Day celebrates 13th year

1:53
FEMA awards Babbitt Court with grant to raise homes to reduce flooding

FEMA awards Babbitt Court with grant to raise homes to reduce flooding

1:20
Headlines: Putnam Valley man dies in excavating accident, 2 injured in Newburgh fire, man charged with larceny in Liberty

Headlines: Putnam Valley man dies in excavating accident, 2 injured in Newburgh fire, man charged with larceny in Liberty

2:15
Turn To Tara explores how to stay safe from ‘cyber kidnapping’ scams

Turn To Tara explores how to stay safe from ‘cyber kidnapping’ scams