Latest Suffolk deer culling hits legal snag

Federal authorities say an overabundance of white-tailed deer is endangering the forest of a history Suffolk County property, but their plan for a deer cull is being blocked.

News 12 Staff

Feb 20, 2019, 10:53 PM

Updated 1,896 days ago

Share:

Latest Suffolk deer culling hits legal snag
Federal authorities say an overabundance of white-tailed deer is endangering the forest of a history Suffolk County property, but their plan for a deer cull is being blocked.
People living or working near the William Floyd Estate in Mastic Beach might soon hear the sound of gunshots. Federal employees with the National Park Service and other agencies are supposed to start thinning the deer population, killing more than 100 deer that live on the property. Experts say the deer are devastating the landscape and endangering other wildlife.
"Without intervention, this level of deer threaten[s] the forests' ability to sustain itself over the long term," says Elizabeth Rogers, of the National Park Service.
The plan isn't sitting well with Robert Oliver, who lives right next door.
"I came from the Bronx. I grew up in an apartment building as a kid," Oliver says. "I don't want to kill animals. That's why I'm in the country."
The operation is part of a larger plan to decrease the number of deer on Fire Island, but that isn't scheduled to start until next year. There is also the possibility of a public recreational hunt within the Fire Island wilderness area, but that is only an option as of right now.
Jim Hunter, of the Evelyn Alexander Wildlife Rescue Center in Hampton Bays, says he opposes any plan that requires people to kill animals.
"They have a right to survive the same as we have a right to survive," Hunter says. "And I don't think humans should make that decision."
The hunt was scheduled to begin Wednesday, but three out-of-state animal rights groups filed lawsuits. On Tuesday, a federal judge granted one of the groups a temporary restraining order. A hearing is now scheduled for Thursday.
The William Floyd Estate is currently closed for the winter.


More from News 12
2:16
Officials, community discuss impact of act that will seal certain criminal records

Officials, community discuss impact of act that will seal certain criminal records

2:33
STORM WATCH: Thunderstorms, showers overnight in the Hudson Valley

STORM WATCH: Thunderstorms, showers overnight in the Hudson Valley

0:34
Executives who defrauded White Plains-based OrthoNet sentenced, must pay back millions

Executives who defrauded White Plains-based OrthoNet sentenced, must pay back millions

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

1:45
Community members express ‘bleak’ outlook for City of Newburgh Police Department following chief’s resignation

Community members express ‘bleak’ outlook for City of Newburgh Police Department following chief’s resignation

2:07
Vassar student encampment grows as college leaders respond to students' demands regarding Israel-Hamas war

Vassar student encampment grows as college leaders respond to students' demands regarding Israel-Hamas war

1:45
Harrison holds public hearing on proposed solar project

Harrison holds public hearing on proposed solar project

1:08
Rep. Lawler leads push to codify more strict definition of antisemitism

Rep. Lawler leads push to codify more strict definition of antisemitism

0:31
Fallsburg police search for missing 14-year-old girl

Fallsburg police search for missing 14-year-old girl

0:43
Congressmen call for Metro-North discounts extension to Hudson Valley riders

Congressmen call for Metro-North discounts extension to Hudson Valley riders

0:19
Bronx man charged with criminally negligent homicide in death of Sullivan County man

Bronx man charged with criminally negligent homicide in death of Sullivan County man

1:45
4th annual Diverse Ability Job Fair draws hundreds seeking opportunities

4th annual Diverse Ability Job Fair draws hundreds seeking opportunities

0:34
2 Ulster County brothers convicted of murdering father of 2

2 Ulster County brothers convicted of murdering father of 2

0:19
Middletown man sentenced to 10 years in prison for child rape

Middletown man sentenced to 10 years in prison for child rape

0:26
$24.3 million bond referendum passes, vote makes way for new Thiells fire station

$24.3 million bond referendum passes, vote makes way for new Thiells fire station

0:52
Town of Forestburgh rejects AG James claims of unfair zoning restrictions

Town of Forestburgh rejects AG James claims of unfair zoning restrictions

0:29
Lawmakers demand transparency on Carmel lithium-ion battery storage facility

Lawmakers demand transparency on Carmel lithium-ion battery storage facility

0:48
North Castle police warn residents following weekend car thefts

North Castle police warn residents following weekend car thefts

0:45
Dobbs Ferry condemns racist incidents; urges public vigilance

Dobbs Ferry condemns racist incidents; urges public vigilance

0:22
Westchester County launches initiative to support Asian American and Pacific Islander communities

Westchester County launches initiative to support Asian American and Pacific Islander communities