‘One of the most brutal cases I have seen’ – Brother charged in slaying of family

<p>Prosecutor Christopher Gramiccioni called the killing of a Monmouth County family earlier this month &ldquo;one of the most brutal cases&rdquo; he has ever seen.</p>

News 12 Staff

Nov 29, 2018, 5:08 PM

Updated 1,987 days ago

Share:

Prosecutor Christopher Gramiccioni called the killing of a Monmouth County family earlier this month “one of the most brutal cases” he has ever seen.
Gramiccioni announced Thursday that Paul Caneiro, 51, was charged for the murder of his brother Keith, Keith’s wife Jennifer and the couple’s two children, 11-year-old Jesse and 8-year-old Sophia. Paul Caneiro then allegedly set fire to the Colts Neck home to cover his tracks.
Gramiccioni says Paul Caneiro shot his brother multiple times on the front lawn of the Willow Brook Road mansion in the early morning hours of Nov. 20. The prosecutor says that Paul Caneiro then shot and stabbed Jennifer Caneiro and then stabbed the children. He then set fire to the home in the basement, according to investigators.
"From there we allege that the defendant intentionally set fire at his home at or about 5 a.m. for the purpose of both destroying evidence of his crime in Colts Neck and to also create the illusion that the overall Caneiro family was somehow victimized or targeted,” Gramiccioni said at a news conference.
The prosecutor says that the motive was “financial in nature," stemming from two businesses - a computer systems company called Square One and a pest control business - he and his brother jointly ran in Asbury Park. Gramiccioni declined to elaborate, saying the investigation was incomplete.
The fire at the Colts Neck home burned for hours, causing it to be badly damaged. The area is still fenced off. Friends and loved ones of the Caneiro family have placed signs, photographs and flowers at the site as a memorial to the family. Dozens of Monmouth County residents came out for a candlelight vigil honoring the family a day after their deaths.
Paul Caneiro’s attorneys say that he is innocent.
“There is absolutely no reason in the world for Paul Caneiro to have committed the crimes he is alleged to have committed. He would never hurt any member of his family,” attorneys said in a statement. “The process today can begin for a search for the truth and who committed these horrendous acts.”
Paul Caneiro faces four counts of murder charges, as well as arson and weapons charges. He is expected to appear in court Friday.
The Associated Press wire services contributed to this report.


More from News 12
2:56
VOTE 2024: Latimer makes his case for 16th Congressional District seat

VOTE 2024: Latimer makes his case for 16th Congressional District seat

2:18
Summerlike afternoon with highs in 80, rain and big cool down coming

Summerlike afternoon with highs in 80, rain and big cool down coming

2:02
Day laborers banned from seeking work in parking lot of New Rochelle Home Depot protest

Day laborers banned from seeking work in parking lot of New Rochelle Home Depot protest

1:40
Opening statements begin in Town of Wallkill murder-for-hire trial

Opening statements begin in Town of Wallkill murder-for-hire trial

1:58
4 teens face hate crime charges in Ramapo, accused of antisemitic drive-by harassment

4 teens face hate crime charges in Ramapo, accused of antisemitic drive-by harassment

0:30
‘We are heartbroken.’ Loved ones search for answers in case of missing New Paltz woman

‘We are heartbroken.’ Loved ones search for answers in case of missing New Paltz woman

1:10
Parents, NYCLU rally in Albany to demand changes in E. Ramapo schools

Parents, NYCLU rally in Albany to demand changes in E. Ramapo schools

0:48
Rockland community unites to commemorate Holocaust Remembrance Day

Rockland community unites to commemorate Holocaust Remembrance Day

0:28
Trial of Wallkill man suspected of hiring someone to kill his neighbor begins today

Trial of Wallkill man suspected of hiring someone to kill his neighbor begins today

0:27
Rye police: Car burglary highlights need to lock vehicles

Rye police: Car burglary highlights need to lock vehicles

1:46
Fire officials: Fatal Ossining fire doesn't appear to be suspicious

Fire officials: Fatal Ossining fire doesn't appear to be suspicious

1:14
Headlines: Woman stabbed in White Plains, fatal crash on I-84, body of missing guardsman found

Headlines: Woman stabbed in White Plains, fatal crash on I-84, body of missing guardsman found

0:31
Orange County school districts poised to implement wards for school board elections

Orange County school districts poised to implement wards for school board elections

0:32
SUNY Purchase agrees to suspend disciplinary consequences for protester arrested during campus demonstrations

SUNY Purchase agrees to suspend disciplinary consequences for protester arrested during campus demonstrations

0:19
Rabies alert issued in Sullivan County after fox tests positive

Rabies alert issued in Sullivan County after fox tests positive

0:38
Local thrift store hits $4 million in charitable giving to Northern Westchester hospital

Local thrift store hits $4 million in charitable giving to Northern Westchester hospital

0:40
New York honors fallen police officers with memorial wall dedication

New York honors fallen police officers with memorial wall dedication

0:30
New Rochelle maintains current elementary school start times despite cost concerns

New Rochelle maintains current elementary school start times despite cost concerns

0:21
Small business owners recognized for contributions during Asian Pacific American Heritage Month

Small business owners recognized for contributions during Asian Pacific American Heritage Month