Attorneys, judge debate jury instructions at Menendez trial

<p>Attorneys in the bribery trial of New Jersey U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez are arguing over what legal instructions the jury will hear from the judge before deliberating.</p>

News 12 Staff

Oct 31, 2017, 8:29 PM

Updated 2,361 days ago

Share:

By DAVID PORTER
Associated Press
NEWARK, N.J. (AP) - Attorneys in the bribery trial of U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez gathered on Tuesday to hash out the legal instructions the judge is to give to the jury before deliberations, a crucial phase of the trial in light of a recent Supreme Court decision that has already prompted the overturning of several public corruption convictions.
After eight weeks of testimony, jurors could hear closing arguments from both sides on Wednesday or Thursday.
Menendez, a New Jersey Democrat, is charged with taking gifts from a wealthy donor between 2006 and 2013 in exchange for political influence, including lobbying government officials on behalf of the donor's business interests. The donor, Florida eye doctor Salomon Melgen, also is on trial.
The two men have denied any bribery arrangement and say the gifts, which included flights on Melgen's private jet and a luxury hotel stay in Paris, are an outgrowth of their longtime friendship.
Before jurors hear closing arguments, they will be instructed by U.S. District Judge William Walls on the specifics of the law. That is especially important here because the definition of official bribery was narrowed by the Supreme Court's decision last year that overturned the conviction of former Republican Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell.
Since then, courts have cited the decision to toss the convictions of former New York state lawmakers Sheldon Silver, a Democrat, and Dean Skelos, a Republican, and former Louisiana Rep. William Jefferson, also a Democrat.
The judge in Menendez's trial already denied the defense's motion to throw out the case on the grounds that the prosecution didn't demonstrate a bribery agreement under the McDonnell definitions. Both sides argued Tuesday over how the judge should instruct the jury on those points.
The defense proposed that the judge tell jurors they would have to find Menendez took gifts in exchange for official acts that "were agreed upon at the time of the exchange" to find him guilty. That conforms to language in the McDonnell decision, the defense wrote.
In contrast, prosecutors wrote that the judge should tell jurors they need only find Menendez took a thing of value "corruptly in return for being influenced in the performance of an official act" to find him guilty.
Menendez and Melgen each face six bribery counts, one conspiracy count and four related counts. Menendez also faces one count of making false statements by not reporting Melgen's gifts on Senate disclosure forms.
Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


More from News 12
0:37
Virginia man was sentenced to 20 years to life in fatal 2021 shooting of New Rochelle cab driver

Virginia man was sentenced to 20 years to life in fatal 2021 shooting of New Rochelle cab driver

2:10
Scattered showers for Friday throughout the Hudson Valley before dry, breezy Saturday

Scattered showers for Friday throughout the Hudson Valley before dry, breezy Saturday

0:34
Westchester DA: Yonkers man sentenced 1 1/3 to 4 years in prison for fatal June 2023 hit-and-run

Westchester DA: Yonkers man sentenced 1 1/3 to 4 years in prison for fatal June 2023 hit-and-run

0:28
White Plains police: Teenager arrested in connection to stabbing of 17-year-old outside gas station

White Plains police: Teenager arrested in connection to stabbing of 17-year-old outside gas station

1:54
Cannabis dispensary owners head north to find holy grail of pot sales after being re-zoned

Cannabis dispensary owners head north to find holy grail of pot sales after being re-zoned

0:41
State budget proposal would consolidate Medicaid program used in hiring home health aide

State budget proposal would consolidate Medicaid program used in hiring home health aide

1:35
Double Up Food Bucks program comes to Yonkers market

Double Up Food Bucks program comes to Yonkers market

1:45
Surveillance video captures 58 water trucks in South Blooming Grove neighborhood in one month amid water crisis

Surveillance video captures 58 water trucks in South Blooming Grove neighborhood in one month amid water crisis

0:46
Schuyler Crossing management express frustration with ongoing flooding at affordable housing complex

Schuyler Crossing management express frustration with ongoing flooding at affordable housing complex

Preliminary report uncovers over 100 potential unmarked burials at historic Rye cemetery

Preliminary report uncovers over 100 potential unmarked burials at historic Rye cemetery

1:38
Religious leaders work to salvage sacred Torah scrolls after fire

Religious leaders work to salvage sacred Torah scrolls after fire

0:25
Dutchess County drug raid uncovers crack cocaine, cash, ammo and loaded handgun

Dutchess County drug raid uncovers crack cocaine, cash, ammo and loaded handgun

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

0:19
Suspect in Rockland County stabbing to appear in Ramapo Town Court today

Suspect in Rockland County stabbing to appear in Ramapo Town Court today

0:35
Legal battle over Harrison town supervisor election comes to an end

Legal battle over Harrison town supervisor election comes to an end

1:24
Westchester County launches Pitch In For Parks initiative ahead of Earth Day

Westchester County launches Pitch In For Parks initiative ahead of Earth Day

0:32
Out-of-court settlement reached in New Rochelle excessive force lawsuit

Out-of-court settlement reached in New Rochelle excessive force lawsuit

3:05
Rising concerns over marijuana addiction ahead of 4/20

Rising concerns over marijuana addiction ahead of 4/20

1:44
Discover a Gothic Revival masterpiece of art and architecture at Lyndhurst Mansion

Discover a Gothic Revival masterpiece of art and architecture at Lyndhurst Mansion

0:51
Save money while helping the planet with these 12 energy-efficient tips

Save money while helping the planet with these 12 energy-efficient tips