Prosecutors: Dix Hills man starved dog to point of emaciation

<p>Prosecutors say a nurse from Dix Hills made up a lost-and-found story about his neglected dog Oakley, who starved to the point of emaciation.</p>

News 12 Staff

Jan 11, 2018, 12:22 AM

Updated 2,294 days ago

Share:

Prosecutors say a nurse from Dix Hills made up a lost-and-found story about his neglected dog Oakley, who starved to the point of emaciation.
Paul Matthews faces a slew of charges including torturing and injuring animals, failure to provide sustenance to an animal and abandonment of animals.
Prosecutors say an examination revealed that Oakley was severely malnourished and weighed only 57 pounds – about 25 pounds underweight. They say an X-ray revealed sheetrock and steel debris in his stomach.
"He had no nutrition in his stomach, only rocks, steel, leaves and grass," says Jed Painter, an assistant district attorney in Nassau County. "Starving dogs will eat anything to survive, in this case, it was causing a lot of damage, possibly a blockage."
Oakley was near death when Matthews surrendered him to the Town of Hempstead Animal Shelter on Dec. 21, according to prosecutors. They say Matthews made up a story about finding the dog on Jericho Turnpike as a stray. 
A veterinarian determined the dog had been starved for about three months.
Prosecutors say an investigation found Matthews had been Oakley's owner and caregiver for at least two years. 
"You can't watch your animal waste away," Painter says. "You can't knowingly neglect your animal."
The dog underwent surgery and is doing better. Once he makes a full recovery, prosecutors say he'll be put up for adoption.
Matthews is due back in court Feb. 22.
No one answered the door at his Dix Hills home.


More from News 12
0:31
President Joe Biden to visit Village of Irvington for celebrity fundraiser

President Joe Biden to visit Village of Irvington for celebrity fundraiser

2:39
Mary J. Blige’s Road to the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame started in Yonkers public housing

Mary J. Blige’s Road to the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame started in Yonkers public housing

2:06
Frost and freeze concerns overnight, glorious Tuesday with temps in the 60s

Frost and freeze concerns overnight, glorious Tuesday with temps in the 60s

2:04
‘She wore her uniform proudly.’ Westchester COBA mourns late officer Eleanor Birrittella

‘She wore her uniform proudly.’ Westchester COBA mourns late officer Eleanor Birrittella

2:19
Turn to Tara team looks at new domestic violence laws implemented across tri-state following NJ murder-suicide

Turn to Tara team looks at new domestic violence laws implemented across tri-state following NJ murder-suicide

1:45
West Point’s Keller Army Hospital, Hudson Valley VA form partnership to expand access

West Point’s Keller Army Hospital, Hudson Valley VA form partnership to expand access

1:56
Armonk twins showcase baking skills for Passover

Armonk twins showcase baking skills for Passover

0:21
Orange County man killed in Sullivan County motorcycle crash

Orange County man killed in Sullivan County motorcycle crash

0:36
Yonkers native Mary J. Blige, Queens hip-hop group A Tribe Called Quest selected for Rock Hall of Fame

Yonkers native Mary J. Blige, Queens hip-hop group A Tribe Called Quest selected for Rock Hall of Fame

0:38
Better Than Ezra to headline Pleasantville Music Festival this summer

Better Than Ezra to headline Pleasantville Music Festival this summer

0:39
Slithering success: NY Metro Reptile Expo draws crowds to Westchester County Center

Slithering success: NY Metro Reptile Expo draws crowds to Westchester County Center

0:58
Headlines: Shooting in Poughkeepsie, New Rochelle assault, shooting threat in Beacon

Headlines: Shooting in Poughkeepsie, New Rochelle assault, shooting threat in Beacon

0:19
Traffic Alert: Gilchrest Road closed for construction upgrades in Valley Cottage

Traffic Alert: Gilchrest Road closed for construction upgrades in Valley Cottage

1:29
$3 million road construction project could impact drivers in Nanuet

$3 million road construction project could impact drivers in Nanuet

0:29
Fishkill police rescue quartet of ducklings from storm drain drama

Fishkill police rescue quartet of ducklings from storm drain drama

0:28
Yonkers volunteers clean up Old Croton Aqueduct trail in honor of Earth Week

Yonkers volunteers clean up Old Croton Aqueduct trail in honor of Earth Week

0:34
Hundreds rally in Newburgh to support Habitat for Humanity

Hundreds rally in Newburgh to support Habitat for Humanity

0:39
Local musicians compete for spots at Pleasantville Music Festival

Local musicians compete for spots at Pleasantville Music Festival

0:21
Fire crews contain transformer fire at Jackie Jones Tower

Fire crews contain transformer fire at Jackie Jones Tower

0:20
Port Jervis welcomes Azure Candle & Co with grand opening event

Port Jervis welcomes Azure Candle & Co with grand opening event