Lawmaker: Survey finds dismal LIRR satisfaction rates

<p>According to Sen. Todd Kaminsky, who created the survey, the results are dismal.</p>

News 12 Staff

Sep 18, 2018, 9:43 AM

Updated 2,045 days ago

Share:

A LIRR satisfaction report was released Tuesday after state lawmakers unveiled a proposal to block planned LIRR fare hikes.
According to state Sen. Todd Kaminsky, who created the survey, the results are dismal.
Nearly 600 commuters were asked about their LIRR experience, and they expressed extreme dissatisfaction with the timeliness, quality and value of the train service.
A total of 318 people said that they were dissatisfied, 109 said that they were moderately satisfied and 48 people said they were satisfied.
The results mark a significant difference from the 77 percent satisfaction rate reported by the LIRR following a poll it conducted.
Sen. Kaminsky describes the current commuter experience as miserable and chaotic, and is demanding that MTA take immediate action before instituting a fare increase.
Kaminsky said the survey was seven to eight questions about satisfaction with LIRR service. The questions were based on timeliness of the LIRR, quality and value of train service.
Only 13 percent of responders said they believed that they got their money's worth. Kaminsky says the survey shows that an overwhelming number of commuters are absolutely not satisfied.
Despite having its worst on-time performance in 19 years, the LIRR has planned a 4 percent fare hike for early next year. On Monday, Republican lawmakers proposed new legislation to stop it.
An MTA spokesperson tells News 12 they are working on infrastructure, which should help with timeliness.
But Kaminsky is calling on the railroad to acknowledge its current state.
“The on-time statistics that the railroad keep are not accurate. They do not reflect what is going on out there, and we have to get rid of the false advertising that things are good,” he says. “We are going to tackle a problem so central to Long Island, we have to come to grips with the nature of the situation. It's simple - it's very bad.”
Regarding the false advertising, Kaminsky was referring to the 77 percent satisfaction rate that the LIRR reported in a poll last year. He said those numbers are absolutely wrong. He also said many people and officials thought that Penn Station was horrible.
News 12 reached out to the LIRR for comment, but has not heard back yet.


More from News 12
1:49
Human remains unearthed during drainage work in Putnam County

Human remains unearthed during drainage work in Putnam County

0:56
Sunny for the rest of the workweek ahead before possible wet weekend in Hudson Valley

Sunny for the rest of the workweek ahead before possible wet weekend in Hudson Valley

2:30
Biden campaign reports blockbuster fundraising hauls ahead of visit

Biden campaign reports blockbuster fundraising hauls ahead of visit

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

2:07
​Officials hope to implement noise cameras to combat loud noise from street racing in Greenburgh

​Officials hope to implement noise cameras to combat loud noise from street racing in Greenburgh

Carmel Board of Education expected to approve budget that cuts more than $5 million

Carmel Board of Education expected to approve budget that cuts more than $5 million

0:36
Police: Father pleads guilty to string of burglaries from 2022

Police: Father pleads guilty to string of burglaries from 2022

0:31
Yonkers official calls for protection of city’s war memorial from graffiti, vandalism

Yonkers official calls for protection of city’s war memorial from graffiti, vandalism

0:40
Hochul: $33 million allocated to mental health in the state budget to expand services for felons

Hochul: $33 million allocated to mental health in the state budget to expand services for felons

0:57
Airlines will now be required to give automatic cash refunds for canceled and delayed flights

Airlines will now be required to give automatic cash refunds for canceled and delayed flights

0:28
Police officer's conduct under review following shoplifting incident at Newburgh Walmart

Police officer's conduct under review following shoplifting incident at Newburgh Walmart

0:31
Mount St. Mary College welcomes new president

Mount St. Mary College welcomes new president

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

Vote 2024: Ask your questions for Congressional District 16 Democratic candidates

0:41
Fire destroys car, damages garage in Rhinebeck

Fire destroys car, damages garage in Rhinebeck

1:49
Proposal for Putnam County lithium-ion battery storage station raises concerns in Westchester

Proposal for Putnam County lithium-ion battery storage station raises concerns in Westchester

0:32
Repeat offender arrested on trespassing charge in Ulster County

Repeat offender arrested on trespassing charge in Ulster County

News 12 Westchester/Hudson Valley Daily Poll

News 12 Westchester/Hudson Valley Daily Poll

0:18
President Biden to deliver commencement address at West Point

President Biden to deliver commencement address at West Point

0:24
Spring Valley man convicted for violating order of protection and resisting arrest

Spring Valley man convicted for violating order of protection and resisting arrest

0:28
President Biden's visit prompts early dismissals in Westchester schools

President Biden's visit prompts early dismissals in Westchester schools