'Nobody expected it': The monster storm that pummeled LI 80 years ago

<p>Long Islanders were going about their business, oblivious to the Category 3 hurricane that was racing their way with the speed of an express train.</p>

News 12 Staff

Sep 21, 2018, 2:47 PM

Updated 2,049 days ago

Share:

'Nobody expected it': The monster storm that pummeled LI 80 years ago
Long before Florence, Maria, Sandy or Irene, there was the "Long Island Express" -- one of the most powerful storms in modern times that barreled into the South Shore with little warning and forever altered Long Island's geography.
That day on Sept. 21, 1938, Long Islanders were going about their business, oblivious to the Category 3 hurricane that was racing their way with the speed of an express train.
Otis Bradley was a child growing up in Westhampton when it hit, but he still remembers the Hurricane of 1938 like it was yesterday.
"At noon the hurricane hit and it was devastating, and nobody expected it," Bradley recalls. "It came and came, and all of a sudden the house that we were in was underwater. It went from the first floor to the second floor to the third floor."
The hurricane formed in the eastern Atlantic on Sept. 15, and in days it had become a 160-mph monster. Forecasters expected the storm to move out to sea, but instead it sped straight toward Long Island.
Lois Davis was in school in Westhampton the day the storm hit.  
"One by one, you would see the cherry trees come down just like that on the cars - but you didn’t hear a thing.  All you heard was the wind, which blew and blew and blew, and was very frightening," Davis says.
Winds gusted to 120 mph. The hurricane packed a 12- to 15-foot storm surge with 30-foot waves that combined to destroy thousands of homes. The storm caused more than 60 deaths Island-wide. 
The water on Main Street in Westhampton got as high as 8 feet, according to Jon Stanat, of the town's historical society. But Dune Road bore the brunt of the storm's fury.
"Almost all of the houses out there had been washed away," Stanat says. "I think there were close to 180 houses on Dune Road before the storm, and only 26 afterwards."
The storm moved with such speed that people had little time to prepare.
"I remember seeing my father come up from the farm and said, 'We have to get out of here, I just saw a house come over the bridge right down the road by our duck farm,'" says Jean Wilcox Tuttle, of Speonk.
After battering Long Island, the hurricane roared into New England. In all, 700 people lost their lives in what remains the strongest hurricane to hit the Northeast in modern times.


More from News 12
1:29
Elmsford School District addresses elimination of DEI director role

Elmsford School District addresses elimination of DEI director role

2:01
Summer feeling with highs in the 80s tomorrow in the Hudson Valley

Summer feeling with highs in the 80s tomorrow in the Hudson Valley

1:22
Pro-Palestinian protests make their way to SUNY New Paltz campus

Pro-Palestinian protests make their way to SUNY New Paltz campus

0:20
Guy Fieri to host Cinco de Mayo bottle signing event in Yonkers

Guy Fieri to host Cinco de Mayo bottle signing event in Yonkers

0:27
White Plains and Northern Westchester Hospitals given 'A' grades for patient safety

White Plains and Northern Westchester Hospitals given 'A' grades for patient safety

1:33
SUNY officials visit Yonkers to encourage high schoolers to complete financial aid applications

SUNY officials visit Yonkers to encourage high schoolers to complete financial aid applications

0:35
 Woman faces charges in assault incident at Yonkers Montessori Academy

Woman faces charges in assault incident at Yonkers Montessori Academy

1:48
Newburgh charity founder faces federal charges, accused of falsely claiming to be a Purple Heart recipient and stealing from the VA

Newburgh charity founder faces federal charges, accused of falsely claiming to be a Purple Heart recipient and stealing from the VA

Poughkeepsie Police investigate shootings of two teens, shooter at large

Poughkeepsie Police investigate shootings of two teens, shooter at large

0:30
Rockland County's American Eel Project underway

Rockland County's American Eel Project underway

0:53
Health care workers picket outside Phelps Hospital demanding better conditions

Health care workers picket outside Phelps Hospital demanding better conditions

0:41
Sen. Gillibrand announces passage of new bill to fight fentanyl crisis

Sen. Gillibrand announces passage of new bill to fight fentanyl crisis

0:31
Car drives into Whoo's Bar and Grill in Newburgh forcing its closure

Car drives into Whoo's Bar and Grill in Newburgh forcing its closure

0:33
Changes to recreational striped bass fishing regulations in the Hudson River

Changes to recreational striped bass fishing regulations in the Hudson River

0:20
Arrest made in Spring Valley stabbing case

Arrest made in Spring Valley stabbing case

0:31
Putnam County man killed in crash following pursuit

Putnam County man killed in crash following pursuit

0:51
Westchester County allocates $3 million for affordable housing in Mamaroneck

Westchester County allocates $3 million for affordable housing in Mamaroneck

2:15
Hazy and hot weather arrives Thursday before a weekend cooldown

Hazy and hot weather arrives Thursday before a weekend cooldown

0:32
Suspect arrested in fatal shooting at unlicensed cannabis store in Mount Vernon

Suspect arrested in fatal shooting at unlicensed cannabis store in Mount Vernon

0:56
Homeless man arrested for 20th time in Ulster County for possessing stolen items

Homeless man arrested for 20th time in Ulster County for possessing stolen items