News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Impound nightmare: Woman gets vehicle returned after she says police made huge mistake

The officer said the vehicle was stolen and had an altered VIN. Her friend was arrested and charged with multiple crimes, including grand larceny.

Nadia Galindo

Dec 5, 2024, 6:43 AM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A Pennsylvania woman says she has a small sense of relief after finally getting her 2018 Range Rover back.

As News 12 first reported, Marlyn Benjamin's vehicle was impounded by the NYPD in October after her friend was pulled over by police after dropping off Benjamin and her mother, who is battling cancer at a hospital for treatment.

The officer said the vehicle was stolen and had an altered VIN. Her friend was arrested and charged with multiple crimes, including grand larceny.

"I bought this car from a dealership," Benjamin said. "I know this car is registered, the car was inspected."

Her mother died two weeks after the incident, and Benjamin said instead of spending her time with her ailing mother, she was at the 73rd Precinct trying to prove the vehicle police had in their possession was legally hers and that they had made a mistake.

"I was treated like a criminal, like I did something wrong," she said.

On Monday, the NYPD finally released the vehicle to Benjamin after she hired an attorney who found out that it was police who actually put the wrong VIN on the paperwork and the car was in fact released from their custody - eight days after police seized it.

"It ended up, they saying I abandoned the car," Benjamin said.

The Brooklyn District Attorney's Office confirmed to News 12 the charges against Benjamin's friend have been dismissed.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:29
RTWCHVEliotEngelMemorialCWilkinson10pm_2026-05-17-22-11-26

Memorial service honoring former U.S. Rep. Eliot Engel held at Lehman College

02:04
FX Headlines 10.png HV (2)

Summer-like heat continues across the Hudson Valley before midweek storms bring cooler temperatures

00:25
0517sprainbrookfatalax_2026-05-17-12-08-27

One person dead in Sprain Brook Parkway crash

01:50
RTWCHVLorraineHansberryNameCWilkinson4pm_2026-05-17-16-14-50

Lorraine Hansberry Way: Renowned Croton playwright honored with street renaming 

01:37
RTWCHVRyeBathhouseRenovationJHopwood4pm_2026-05-17-16-17-24

Historic Rye Bath House at Oakland Beach reopens following $2M renovation

01:49
WCMIRACLELEAGUESOFTBALLGAME05174P_2026-05-17-16-36-54

Miracle League baseball game highlights inclusion and community in Westchester

00:40
0516fatalax_2026-05-16-13-33-46

State troopers identify person killed in 3-vehicle crash on Bear Mountain State Parkway

02:04
RTWCHVYonkersKnockoutsCWilkinson9pm_2026-05-16-21-10-51

Crowds pack Downtown Yonkers venue to cheer on young boxing hopefuls

00:53
RTWCHVYonkersArtsKickoffABrownVOSOT4pm_2026-05-16-16-32-03

Yonkers Arts Weekend transforms city into a vibrant creative hub

01:28
RTWCHVPlaylandSoftOpenJHopwood4pm_2026-05-16-16-26-57

Rye Playland reopens for soft launch; Dragon Coaster expected to reopen May 23

03:03
LIRR Strike

LIRR UPDATES: LIRR union leader says bargaining talks with the MTA will resume Monday morning as LIRR strike enters Day 3

01:17
0516spcadogwalk_2026-05-16-13-28-19

Wagging tails and second chances: SPCA Westchester Dog Walk brings hundreds to Yorktown

01:40
0515elmsfordprotest2_2026-05-15-17-46-26

Parents, students protest alleged forced resignations in Elmsford School District

01:52
0515newroprotest_2026-05-15-17-21-28

New Rochelle restores elementary band, orchestra funding after community pushback

01:23
blaise monroe

Surveillance video shows van crash into Monroe insurance office

01:33
0515mtvernondeed_2026-05-15-17-28-40

Mount Vernon officials warn about deed theft

01:40
5152026WC12diane_2026-05-15-12-18-51

Ramapo police investigate reports of people sprayed, hit with objects in Monsey

01:50
0515poughkeepsiedowntown_2026-05-15-18-20-53

Housing, bars and groceries: Poughkeepsie leaders plan to upgrade downtown through coveted state grant

news12

Connecticut Department of Health urges shellfish safety from imported products amid hepatitis A investigation

Harvey Weinstein

Harvey Weinstein rape retrial ends in mistrial as jury deadlocks

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices