News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Judge dismisses Rockland election results lawsuit seeking recount of 2024 results

State Supreme Court Judge Rachel Tanguay has dismissed a lawsuit filed by SMART Legislation that was seeking a hand recount in 2024 presidential and U.S. Senate election results in Rockland County.

Diane Caruso

Dec 16, 2025, 5:14 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

State Supreme Court Judge Rachel Tanguay dismissed a lawsuit filed by SMART Legislation that was seeking a hand recount in 2024 presidential and U.S. Senate election results in Rockland County.

Judge Tanguay's decision stated they "lacked standing" and other legal requirements.

In a statement to News 12, Rockland's Board of Elections says they plan to "continue to administer and certify election results in accordance with all applicable laws and procedures.”

"We consider this a victory, even though we didn't get a hand count. We got a tremendous amount of information in discovery," said Lulu Friesdat, with SMART Legislation.

She adds they learned about the way passwords to voting machines are handled, received conflicting information, among other things.

Friesdat says they are glad they brought the lawsuit,

"We want to emphasize the case was not dismissed on its merits," said Friesdat.

One of SMART Legislation's claims involved a third-party candidate for New York's U.S. Senate seat. Rockland resident Diane Sare had sworn affidavits from more voters than what is reflected in the result totals for two districts.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:29
blaise burglaries

EXCLUSIVE: Suspects wanted in overnight string of smash-and-grab burglaries at multiple businesses

01:49
ML Headlines - 3 Lines (2)

Rainy Saturday with some dry times for Mother's Day

00:23
0509fallenstatue_2026-05-09-11-11-21

Statue falls and injures man at Somers church

01:01
0509runyoury_2026-05-09-11-14-00

Yonkers 'Run Your Y' 5K promotes mental health awareness month 

00:26
59teacherarrested_2026-05-09-07-27-16

Former New Rochelle teacher accused of threatening superintendent extradited from Louisiana

01:28
WCWPPARKINGGARAGE05085P_2026-05-08-17-13-30

Community concerns grow for infrastructure issues at Chester-Maple Parking Garage

02:03
STEM MS 050826_2026-05-08-22-13-46

STEM-tastic event sparks curiosity for local students in Rye

02:01
WCFORMERNICUPATIENT05085P_2026-05-08-17-25-40

Hudson Valley woman gives back to Valhalla NICU that saved her life

01:37
58lisanoon_2026-05-08-12-02-46

Antisemitic symbol being investigated at Nyack High School

01:27
Screenshot 2026-05-08 172957

First female firefighter makes history in Sloatsburg

00:31
5082026DEERPARKSPEEDRACING_2026-05-08-06-18-34

Crackdown on dangerous illegal street activity in Orange County

01:42
0507beaglesrescued_2026-05-07-17-24-29

10 beagles rescued from commercial breeder arrive in Westchester

00:50
58blaisestory_2026-05-08-07-46-54

Walden village board fires manager John Revella amid ongoing investigations

AP26127684140258

US will start revoking passports for thousands of parents who owe child support, AP learns

00:43
WCRAMAPOCRASH05075P_2026-05-07-17-20-07

Taxi flips after driver reportedly falls asleep in Ramapo

01:40
blaise hantavirus

'What's happening right now is very real.' Man documents life aboard expedition ship tied to hantavirus outbreak

01:47
RTWCHVMiddletownBartenderCrashBNandy5pm_2026-05-05-17-44-02

Community raises funds for Orange County bartender seriously injured in crash

01:43
Screenshot 2026-05-07 172437

Two Westchester-based EMS organizations are calling for additional funding, as costs nationwide increase

01:48
0507statebudget_2026-05-07-22-15-13

Local lawmakers react to budget confusion in Albany

01:10
572026WC12newburgh_2026-05-07-12-11-49

Newburgh mother says nonverbal son was ignored during school bus medical emergency

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices