The Town of Chester’s comptroller is fighting back against allegations of misconduct, claiming the town supervisor knew about and approved his work for a neighboring municipality.
Neil Meyer, who is on paid administrative leave, appeared alongside his attorney, Michael Sussman, at a news conference Wednesday in Goshen to defend his actions and question why Chester Supervisor Brandon Holdridge has not publicly acknowledged his alleged involvement.
Meyer is facing scrutiny over his use of a Chester-issued laptop to remotely access financial records for the Town of Wallkill, where he says he was volunteering his time to assist the town with its finances during a fiscal shortfall.
Both Meyer and Sussman insist the arrangement was authorized and that Meyer did nothing inappropriate.
Meyer described the allegations against him as “political” and suggested someone is trying to force him out of his position. According to Meyer and Sussman, Holdridge initially suggested that Meyer assist Wallkill and gave him permission to do so.
“Brandon Holdridge should’ve ended this immediately by saying publicly, I approved this,” Sussman said.
Sussman argued that Meyer continued fulfilling his responsibilities in Chester while providing limited assistance to Wallkill.
“The idea that Neil misused time is nonsense,” Sussman said.
To support their claims, Meyer and his attorney provided computer access records showing approximately 11 hours of logged sessions between June and October, including several on weekends.

Meyer also addressed concerns about cybersecurity, saying the Chester-issued laptop was not connected to the town’s internal server while he remotely accessed Wallkill’s financial system through a cloud-based connection. He said his access to Wallkill’s system was read-only. The comptroller and his attorney also questioned Holdridge’s handling of the controversy, alleging he was not forthcoming about his role in the arrangement when questions first surfaced before the election.
Sussman, who ran for Orange County executive, praised Meyer as a highly qualified and dedicated public servant. He said he had planned to appoint Meyer as county comptroller had he won the election.
Meyer previously served on the Town of Wallkill’s Town Board and ran for Wallkill town supervisor. He was appointed Chester comptroller in January 2024.
Wallkill Supervisor Frank DenDanto told News 12 that he authorized Meyer’s unpaid assistance and read-only access to the town’s financial records. DenDanto also said Meyer did nothing inappropriate or unauthorized.
Holdridge has declined to comment on the matter while the investigation is ongoing.