News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

John Oliver to send stove and grill to Kingston bakery after staff meets 'Cake Bear' challenge

HBO host John Oliver extended a challenge to a Kingston bakery, and the bakery responded with a new line of cakes bearing a photo of Oliver's face on edible candy paper.

Ben Nandy

Jun 10, 2024, 6:11 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

HBO host John Oliver extended a challenge to a Kingston bakery, and the bakery responded with a new line of cakes bearing a photo of Oliver's face on edible candy paper.

"We're really speechless here," Peter Deising, co-owner of Deising's Bakery and Restaurant in Kingston, said of the eatery's newfound fame that came because of a note on a door and a request from Oliver, host of 'Last Week Tonight.'

In the June 2 episode of "Last Week Tonight," in a segment highlighting the downfall and subsequent asset-stripping of Red Lobster, Oliver announced he had purchased all of the contents of the chain's Ulster County location through an online auction and recreated the Red Lobster in his studio.

Shortly after the restaurant closed, Deising's co-owner Eric Deising posted a note on the front door asking to buy a flat grill and convection oven if available, and later learned Oliver had already snatched up all the equipment.

News 12 aired a feature story on Deising missing out on purchasing the equipment, which caught the attention of the "Last Week Tonight" team.

Then this past Sunday evening, Oliver closed his show with a Red Lobster follow-up and a challenge.

He said the equipment was donated and did not include the items the Deisings were seeking, but had a better offer.

"The good news is, we're willing to buy those items for you on one condition," Oliver began. "All I want in return is a baked good with my face on it on sale in your bakery, specifically a cake bear with my face on it. I want to be a cake bear!"

Oliver perused Deising's items and customer reviews online, coming across a photo of a cake bear from Deising's that he gushed about to his audience.

"I don't like cake bears," he said. "I [expletive deleted] love cake bears!"

Challenge accepted.

"At 3 this morning, we were brainstorming and trying to figure out exactly what we were going to do," Peter Deising said Monday morning of the challenge.

The first batch of about 80 John Oliver cake bears – each with a little bear nose on the edible photo of Oliver – sold out in under an hour.

"It's unbelievable," Peter Deising said of the whole experience. "I can't believe it went viral, and the amount of emails and messages on social media that we're getting. People want them shipped to like the Philippines and Australia."

Peter Deising said the restaurant cannot ship perishable goods through the mail, but said all visitors are welcome.

"I was a little shocked," Deising's cake decorator Jenna Ice said. "I can't believe this is real life right now. I thought it was hilarious. He had me laughing pretty good."

The staff also baked a larger bear cake for Oliver, with an extra large behind per Oliver's preference.

Deising's is selling the smaller cakes for $8 each, and sending all the proceeds to Peoples' Place Food Pantry in Kingston.

Challenge met.

A representative of "Last Week Tonight" said Monday the grill and oven should arrive at Deising's later this week.

827854aa-1264-4eb1-b2b9-ca29efdc426a.jpg


More Stories

Top Stories

00:46
LI12PMBRENTWOODFIRE_2026-04-18-12-26-16

Brentwood house fire leaves one person displaced

02:03
CX Headlines 4 (13)

Rainy and raw Sunday for Long Island followed by a cold blast for early next week

01:03
RTLIDrunkDrivingAwarenessVOSOTVO10pm_2026-04-18-22-28-06

Roslyn students hold 2nd annual Drunk Driving Community Awareness Walk

01:40
LI5PMJEREMYPROM_2026-04-18-17-12-52

Suffolk police help students find the right prom look without the cost

02:09
LI5PMDUCKSKEVIN_2026-04-18-17-13-35

New Duck's pitcher hopes to revive his baseball career on Long Island

02:03
Daycare Abuse MS 041726_2026-04-17-22-10-31

Exclusive: Northport day care owner responds to abuse allegations; former employees speak out

00:20
55e50874-3fbc-4e34-a213-f483dfdd2781

Man charged with DWI, fleeing scene of Water Mill crash

01:29
LI12PMLINEWORKERS_2026-04-18-12-20-24

Long Island celebrates National Lineworker Appreciation Day

Serious crash in New Haven critically injures 2 people

Man seriously injured in 2-vehicle Medford crash

CREDIT: AP/HASSAN AMMAR

Iran closes Strait of Hormuz again over US blockade and fires on ships

00:14
Kid Window MS 041726_2026-04-17-22-17-01

4-year-old boy injured after falling out of second-floor window in Huntington Station

00:32
418GOTTISENTENCING_2026-04-18-13-15-30

Federal prosecutors say mob boss John Gotti's grandson's sentencing should not be impacted by kidney donation

00:51
Fire Return MS 041726_2026-04-17-22-15-39

Deer Park residents move back home after apartment fire

01:51
li5pmbolkevinbridge_2026-04-17-17-43-59

Emergency repairs underway on Smith Point Bridge ahead of beach season

02:51
LIEISHENHOW41726_2026-04-17-06-03-36_05-02-09,28

Police: Shooter in custody, teen victim believed to be second shooter at Eisenhower Park

00:20
baiting hollow fire

Firefighter hurt battling blaze at Baiting Hollow home

01:35
Vet Village MS 041726_2026-04-17-17-14-24

New housing complex in Island Park aims to help homeless veterans

01:26
Injured Cat MS 041726_2026-04-17-17-22-52

‘Lucky to Be Alive.’ Cat rescued along LIRR tracks still recovering

00:33
LIMTARIDERSHIP417_2026-04-17-05-59-30

MTA weekend ridership recovering better than weekday numbers post-pandemic

00:27
atv stolen

2 people wanted for stealing 3 off-road vehicles from East Northport home

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices