News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Fair or Mostly Sunny
55°
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Key to stealing your mail: Master key to America's mailboxes fuels growing mail theft problem

Known as an Arrow key, the device has become the focus of growing concerns among law enforcement officials, postal workers and victims of mail theft as thefts of the keys continue to rise.

Kevin Vesey

•

Nov 17, 2026, 12:38 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A small metal key used by postal workers across the country has become a prized tool for mail thieves, allowing criminals to gain access to entire networks of mailboxes and steal checks, personal information and other valuable mail.

Known as an Arrow key, the device has become the focus of growing concerns among law enforcement officials, postal workers and victims of mail theft as thefts of the keys continue to rise.

Postal officials use Arrow keys to open collection boxes and other outdoor mail receptacles within designated areas. But once the keys fall into the wrong hands, criminals can gain widespread access to mailboxes and the contents inside them.

For Mike LoMonico, the consequences were costly.

LoMonico became the victim of check fraud after one of his mailed checks was intercepted, altered and fraudulently cashed for nearly $5,000.

"They need a new system. They need to figure this out. There's got to be a better way," LoMonico said.

Mail theft has emerged as a significant problem across the New York metropolitan region and around the country, with criminals often targeting checks that can be "washed" and rewritten for larger amounts before being deposited or cashed.

According to data from the U.S. Postal Inspection Service, 78 Arrow keys were stolen in New York State last year, more than the total number stolen during all previous years combined since 2021.

Connecticut has also experienced significant thefts. The state recorded 82 stolen Arrow keys in 2023, the highest annual total in recent years. Approximately 60 keys were reported stolen in both 2024 and 2025, and another 40 had already been stolen this year.

Authorities say the keys can be sold illegally online and, in some cases, counterfeited, making them a valuable commodity in criminal circles.

"The Arrow key system was created in 1922," said Frank Albergo, executive director of the Postal Police Officers Association. "So it's over a century old. That's technology from over a century ago. It's basically a piece of tin. They're easily counterfeited."

Critics argue the aging system has become increasingly vulnerable as organized mail theft operations target postal workers and mail collection boxes.

While the U.S. Postal Inspection Service declined an on-camera interview, the agency said in a statement that it has stepped up enforcement efforts. Officials reported more than 4,500 arrests related to mail theft and postal robberies since 2023.

The agency also says it is working to modernize mailbox security nationwide.

In a statement, the Postal Inspection Service said it has deployed "thousands of high-security blue collection boxes" and "tens of thousands of new electronic locking mechanisms" across the country. Officials say the electronic systems can effectively deactivate stolen keys and prevent criminals from using them to gain access to mail.

The upgraded technology is now being deployed in all 50 states.

Despite those efforts, some consumers remain skeptical.

"Somebody's got to be able to figure out how to stop this," LoMonico said.

PART 2: Key to stealing your mail: Postal Service upgrades mailbox security, but critics say millions of aging locks remain

Top Stories

00:57
Screenshot 2026-11-17 055516

Former Westchester school administrator arrested on child sex abuse material charges

appleJG_2024-03-22-07-28-17

Apple Music, App Store experiencing outages; some iCloud users reporting issues

01:11
F P1 AM 1

Bright sunny skies and milder air take over in the Hudson Valley

01:52
Mail Key P1

Key to stealing your mail: Master key to America's mailboxes fuels growing mail theft problem

02:01
Mail Key P2

Key to stealing your mail part 2: Postal Service upgrades mailbox security, but critics say millions of aging locks remain

00:19
Great American Smokeout

Westchester County encouraging residents to quit tobacco

00:24
731f8c36-bee4-4930-b1ec-bb117122cd40

Suspected explosive devices, silencer and rifle found during Pleasant Valley weapons arrest

01:50
Image (1)

59-year-old man dies after being found shot inside vehicle in Yonkers

00:32
Screenshot 2026-11-17 045514

Cold cases of two Carmel girls get renewed attention from joint task force

01:20
Screenshot 2026-11-17 055644

Theater returns to The Drama Book Shop, where ‘In the Heights’ took shape

00:37
LITTLE UNCLE G

Uncle Giuseppe’s unveils ‘Little Uncle G’ holiday plushie toy

01:10
rubix cube

Hot Toys: Classic toys fun for adults and kids

01:17
AP26318607234776

1.5-hour-long system outage forces United Airlines to delay departing flights

LI PERSON BACKGROUND SCHOOL LOCKERS CLASSROOM

District officials: Custodian at Hempstead Elementary School struck student

00:57
green meadow bomb threat

No explosives found after bomb threat reported at Green Meadow Waldorf School

00:25
Teacheraidearrested1116_2026-11-16-16-45-56

Police: Teacher's aide from Sullivan County accused of raping 4-year-old girl over a decade ago

00:19
RTREGWCHVFrankelWinsWorldHockeyGoldVO9pm_2026-11-16-21-35-30

Westchester hockey goalie Frankel wins 2nd Olympic gold medal

00:50
RTREGALLUSLosesMeaslesStatusVOSOTVO9pm_2026-11-16-21-33-39

US loses measles elimination status due to high number of cases

01:17
NewPaltzfire1116_2026-11-16-16-46-08

Firefighters battle massive blaze at New Paltz wine supply business

00:41
WCfatalvailsgatefire1116_2026-11-16-16-46-31

17-year-old killed in Vails Gate house fire; four firefighters injured

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices