News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Pelham Bay community raise concerns about possible homeless shelter

People who live in Pelham Bay are speaking out against a possible homeless shelter that could be coming to their neighborhood.

Lindsay Tanney

Apr 6, 2026, 5:43 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

People who live in Pelham Bay are concerned about a possible homeless shelter that could be coming to their neighborhood.

The proposed site is at 3251 Westchester Ave., which is a vacant storefront near the Pelham Bay Park 6 train station. Community members say the area already has several shelters and worry another one would be too much of a burden for the neighborhood.

“There should not be a homeless shelter over here. There’s already too many,” said Matthew Santiago, who lives nearby.

Some people said they feel for those in need, but think a shelter is not the right fit for this location. Others said they fear their property value will go down and that the shelter would negatively impact the residential, family-oriented neighborhood.

News 12 spoke with a man who says he started a petition calling for more transparency with the community. It currently has more than 1,000 signatures, and thousands of flyers have been handed out in the community, urging residents to contact local elected officials.

According to the Department of Buildings' website, an application has been filed at that address for a five-story building labeled “shelter,” but it has not been accepted and no permits have been issued.

Sources with the Department of Social Services say the community is notified once a project is finalized and approved, and details cannot be shared before then.

Council Member Shirley Aldebol responded with the following statement:

“I believe that the Pelham Bay community within my Council District should not be considered for a proposed shelter. There is already a single adult men’s shelter only a couple of blocks away, and placing a shelter facility here will place an undue burden on the residents of this community. I understand why there is a need to have shelter facilities in varying areas across the city, but the placement should be more purposeful and should not put undue burden on a specific neighborhood. The city needs to focus on the creation of more affordable housing units and pathways to homeownership rather than increase the amount of shelters we have.”

More Stories

Top Stories

01:06
Screenshot 2026-04-14 112834

Second man charged in connection to murder of 7-month-old baby girl walked out of NYPD precinct

01:45
HOPE PLANNER AM

It's a toasty Tuesday in Brooklyn with record heat possible this week

01:14
KLNEDRICKINGSTONAVEFIRE41426530A_2026-04-14-06-01-38

2 people dead after overnight fire in East Flatbush; several displaced, cause under investigation

01:48
AURORAREBUILDINGBK41426530A_2026-04-14-06-21-01

Sunset Park’s BATWorks fuels $100M push for climate innovation

01:36
babyfatallyshotserviceCM_2026-04-13-17-36-17

Funeral services held for 7-month-old baby girl killed by stray bullet in Bushwick

00:53
KLNPDCARSTRUCKPURSUITFOLO41426530A_2026-04-14-05-37-32

NJ man arrested for hitting police cruiser after traffic stop, fled scene

00:22
KLN71YOWOMANASSAULT414630A_2026-04-14-06-38-00

71-year-old woman injured in unprovoked attack in Brighton Beach

01:27
cumberlandwalkhomicideCM_2026-04-13-22-40-09

Fort Greene community mourns beloved artist shot to death outside his home 

02:04
westplaygroundconstructionCM_2026-04-13-22-48-19

West Playground restroom construction enters 11th year

00:39
gravesendpdcrash1030pZC_2026-04-13-22-59-12

Car rams police cruiser, races away during Gravesend traffic stop gone awry

01:01
MT2ARTICLE

Taste of summer: Record-breaking high temperatures possible by Wednesday

00:31
clintonhillmurdersentencing10pZC_2026-04-13-22-08-40

Duo sentenced for gang-related retaliation killing in Clinton Hill

01:17
uspstruckcrash530pZC_2026-04-13-17-41-32

Postal worker hospitalized after collision with double-parked truck in Brownsville

01:46
teenrobbedofjacketCM_2026-04-13-17-35-37

Police search for 15 teenagers who allegedly robbed man at knifepoint in Dyker Heights

02:06
BX5PMHEATHERGROCERY_2026-04-13-17-23-30

Mayor Mamdani unveils location of NYC’s first city-run grocery store

02:14
Screenshot 2026-04-12 at 5.37.31 PM

'You hug your kids extra hard.’ Brooklyn DA reflects on personal connection to fatal shooting of 7-month-old baby in exclusive interview

01:38
birdwoesCM_2026-04-13-17-53-45

Brooklyn birdwatchers concerned about new construction inside Prospect Park

Screenshot 2026-04-13 170613

Mayor Mamdani replaces ‘Homecoming of Heroes’ parade with new 9/11 'Remembrance Ruck'

01:33
RTBKHamiltonPkwyFireRFlaks1030pm_2026-04-12-22-47-01

Fire tears through Borough Park buildings, displacing families; vacate orders posted

00:28
DEATH INVESTIGATION

33‑year‑old woman dies while in custody at Brooklyn Central Booking

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices