Tip leads cops to search lake in 1999 murder mystery

Police and divers combed Crystal Lake in Newburgh Thursday after a tip sparked a new search for a body in a 1999 murder mystery. Dominick Pendino went missing on March 3, 1999. Police say blood was found

News 12 Staff

May 28, 2014, 6:57 PM

Updated 3,646 days ago

Share:

Tip leads cops to search lake in 1999 murder mystery
Police and divers combed Crystal Lake in Newburgh Thursday after a tip sparked a new search for a body in a 1999 murder mystery. Dominick Pendino went missing on March 3, 1999. Police say blood was found all over his Sterling Court driveway in Walkill, but no body was ever found. Larry Weygant and Greg Chrysler, both of Newburgh, were arrested months later and eventually convicted of Pendino?s murder in a landmark case.
Given the amount of blood at the crime scene, a forensic pathologist testified that Pendino must have died. Police have been searching for his remains ever since.
In May 2007, police tore up farmland in Montgomery searching for Pendino?s body. Cadaver-sniffing dogs hit on two spots on the property, but what at first looked promising, turned up nothing. It was the fifteenth property police searched for Pendino?s body.So far, no evidence of the murder turned up in the water. Police did recover three safes and two cars, one that was reported stolen in 2003.
Police say even though two people are in prison for Pendino?s murder, the case will not be over until they find his body.


More from News 12
1:46
Officials: At least 6 injured in multivehicle crash in Putnam County

Officials: At least 6 injured in multivehicle crash in Putnam County

1:42
Mostly sunny skies and warm temperatures in the Hudson Valley

Mostly sunny skies and warm temperatures in the Hudson Valley

0:36
Newburgh Police Commissioner Jose Gomerez resigns

Newburgh Police Commissioner Jose Gomerez resigns

0:49
Former medical officer manager from Orange County pleads guilty to health care fraud

Former medical officer manager from Orange County pleads guilty to health care fraud

0:35
New York State Police identify victim in fatal Sprain Brook Parkway crash

New York State Police identify victim in fatal Sprain Brook Parkway crash

0:38
2 preschoolers injured in fatal Sullivan County school bus crash

2 preschoolers injured in fatal Sullivan County school bus crash

1:48
Several Hudson Valley schools seek to pierce state tax gap in budget votes

Several Hudson Valley schools seek to pierce state tax gap in budget votes

0:17
Yonkers students honor war heroes at 7th Ward War Memorial

Yonkers students honor war heroes at 7th Ward War Memorial

0:26
Police: 2 additional arrests made in 2019 cold case killing of Middletown man

Police: 2 additional arrests made in 2019 cold case killing of Middletown man

2:41
Made in the Hudson Valley: Jaymark Jewelers continues family legacy, four decades in the making

Made in the Hudson Valley: Jaymark Jewelers continues family legacy, four decades in the making

1:41
County manager: School bus driver dies in collision with another school bus

County manager: School bus driver dies in collision with another school bus

1:50
Catskill EMS workers taken off duty after video shows apparent mistreatment of disabled patient

Catskill EMS workers taken off duty after video shows apparent mistreatment of disabled patient

0:57
Parents of late Pace University student receive award at 2024 commencement ceremony

Parents of late Pace University student receive award at 2024 commencement ceremony

1:35
North Castle police: Officer shoots man who attacked police with knife in Armonk

North Castle police: Officer shoots man who attacked police with knife in Armonk

0:49
Saigon Table: New Vietnamese eatery brings healthy fresh food options to Rye

Saigon Table: New Vietnamese eatery brings healthy fresh food options to Rye

1:44
Pride event organizers aim to attract more families while preparing for potential disruptions

Pride event organizers aim to attract more families while preparing for potential disruptions

1:42
Shrub Oak resident: It's only a matter of time until someone is killed on Old Yorktown Road

Shrub Oak resident: It's only a matter of time until someone is killed on Old Yorktown Road

1:56
Remembering Mark Woods: Rockland County reflects on councilman’s life

Remembering Mark Woods: Rockland County reflects on councilman’s life

1:10
Police: Multivehicle crash on Sprain Brook Parkway kills 1

Police: Multivehicle crash on Sprain Brook Parkway kills 1

0:21
Officials: 2 hospitalized following head-on collision in Cornwall

Officials: 2 hospitalized following head-on collision in Cornwall