Trial begins in shooting of Monroe man

Opening statements were heard Thursday in the trial of a New Jersey state park police officer who is accused of killing a Native American man from Monroe. The defense claims that Officer Chad Walder

News 12 Staff

May 27, 2014, 9:42 PM

Updated 3,648 days ago

Share:

Trial begins in shooting of Monroe man
Opening statements were heard Thursday in the trial of a New Jersey state park police officer who is accused of killing a Native American man from Monroe.
The defense claims that Officer Chad Walder was provoked by 45-year-old Emil Mann and was forced to shoot him to preserve his own life. The prosecution, however, insists Walder deliberately pulled the trigger on the victim.
The incident happened April 1, 2006, when Mann attended a cookout at Ringwood State Park in Mahwah, N.J. with family and friends. Assistant Bergen County Prosecutor James Santulli says Mann was caught riding an ATV illegally and had an altercation with Walder that ended with the officer shooting Mann twice in the thigh and chest. Santulli told jurors Walder used bad judgment and panicked.
"He was standing there with his hands up in the air," Santulli says. "He was shot and killed when he didn't have to be."
Defense Attorney Bob Galantucci presented a different version of events. He said Walder heard screaming and saw his lieutenant being attacked by Otis Mann, the victim's cousin. As Walder rushed to help his colleague, Galantucci said, Mann came out from behind a tree and jumped on Walder.
"He was finally able to take his gun out and he said, 'stop,'" Galantucci told the jury. "Mann said, 'shoot me, f---ing shoot me,' and then...he lunged for the gun."
Testimony will resume Tuesday. The trial is expected to last approximately two weeks. If Walder is convicted of manslaughter, he faces 10 years behind bars.


More from News 12
1:40
Officials: Dozens of suspects rounded up in raids as part of ‘largest gun trafficking case’ in Orange County history

Officials: Dozens of suspects rounded up in raids as part of ‘largest gun trafficking case’ in Orange County history

2:25
STORM WATCH: Severe thunderstorms with hail possible Thursday before beautiful conditions on Friday

STORM WATCH: Severe thunderstorms with hail possible Thursday before beautiful conditions on Friday

0:29
$5M in funding awarded to homeless housing project in Newburgh

$5M in funding awarded to homeless housing project in Newburgh

2:31
Questions over affordable housing in Mamaroneck at center of community meeting

Questions over affordable housing in Mamaroneck at center of community meeting

1:45
Rockland school district's $331M budget fails to pass by nearly 400 votes

Rockland school district's $331M budget fails to pass by nearly 400 votes

0:37
ArtsWestchester names long-time official as its CEO

ArtsWestchester names long-time official as its CEO

0:22
Yorktown police: 2 missing Westchester teens located

Yorktown police: 2 missing Westchester teens located

0:33
Hudson Valley Dodge manager killed in incident at dealership

Hudson Valley Dodge manager killed in incident at dealership

2:36
Meet the majority owner of Westchester Soccer Club, the county's new USL team

Meet the majority owner of Westchester Soccer Club, the county's new USL team

1:40
Newburgh school district leaders face difficult choices after voters reject budget

Newburgh school district leaders face difficult choices after voters reject budget

0:40
Police: Minisink school bus aide charged with sexual abuse of 8-year-old girl

Police: Minisink school bus aide charged with sexual abuse of 8-year-old girl

1:41
Mount Vernon catches up on inspections of community public spaces

Mount Vernon catches up on inspections of community public spaces

0:56
Mount Vernon native Sean 'Diddy' Combs faces another sexual assault lawsuit

Mount Vernon native Sean 'Diddy' Combs faces another sexual assault lawsuit

0:22
Poughkeepsie man arrested on drug charges, accused of selling cocaine

Poughkeepsie man arrested on drug charges, accused of selling cocaine

2:45
Chappaqua, East Ramapo, and Newburgh reject school budgets; Clarkstown OKs 4% increase for schools

Chappaqua, East Ramapo, and Newburgh reject school budgets; Clarkstown OKs 4% increase for schools

RESULTS: News 12 Westchester/Hudson Valley School Vote 2024

RESULTS: News 12 Westchester/Hudson Valley School Vote 2024

0:40
Ramapo incident reports list tickets, charges against Monsey bus drivers who struck kids

Ramapo incident reports list tickets, charges against Monsey bus drivers who struck kids

1:10
Headlines: Woman steals $97,000 from business, health insurance fraud, Stony Point home invasion

Headlines: Woman steals $97,000 from business, health insurance fraud, Stony Point home invasion

0:30
Elmsford mayor censured by village board following harassment complaint

Elmsford mayor censured by village board following harassment complaint

0:33
Former State Assemblyman Robert Castelli dies at 74

Former State Assemblyman Robert Castelli dies at 74