News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Celebrating America's 250th

Westchester County legislator wants Rep. Lawler to apologize to community over comments on citizenship status

Controversy is brewing over comments made by Rep. Mike Lawler on a Westchester County legislator's citizenship status.

Melanie Palmer

Feb 19, 2025, 10:15 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Controversy is brewing over comments made by Rep. Mike Lawler on a Westchester County legislator's citizenship status.

It happened during the Westchester County Board of Legislators meeting Tuesday afternoon.

The meeting was with the federal delegation, and Rep. Lawler was there.

"I prompted the question, as the way I look, and if I'm ever approached by ICE, what should I produce as documentation?," asked Westchester County Board of Legislators Vice Chair José Alvarado.

"Like every other person that is engaged by law enforcement, if you are asked for information, cooperate. I wouldn't expect you as a, I assume you are a citizen, maybe you're not, maybe you are but...," Lawler responded.

Alvarado, who is a U.S. citizen, says Lawler's response left him appalled and some other members of the board shocked.

"What is his right to question another duly elected official, high-ranking duly elected official in Westchester County about his citizenship status," says Alvarado.

Lawler addressed his comments a short time later during the meeting.

"Yes, I understand to hold office, you have to be a citizen," Lawler said.

Alvarado was born in Honduras. He has since lived the American dream, he tells News 12. He's the first Latino majority leader with the Westchester County Board of legislators.

He wants an apology from Lawler but not for himself.

"The community needs to hear an apology from him," says Alvarado.

Lawler says that's not going to happen.

"It's not an attack on immigrants but if you're questioned by ICE, you should cooperate," says Lawler.

Many of Alvarado's colleagues are standing by his side.

"I think it was disrespectful," says Chairman Vedat Gashi, with the Westchester County Board of Legislators.

The Democratic Caucus of the Westchester County Board of Legislators released the following statement:

"Rep. Lawler’s actions are deeply disrespectful to the Vice Chairman and an open affront to Latinos and all people of color in Westchester County and beyond. Congressman Lawler should know that all elected officials in this state, including those in Westchester County, must be U.S. citizens to hold office. We stand firmly by our colleague, José Alvarado and demand a full and immediate apology."

More Stories

Top Stories

00:53
Screenshot 2026-06-30 123201

Baby born on way to hospital after surprise delivery in family car

02:06
FB HeatIndex iCast 2

HEAT ALERT: Dangerous, extreme heat builds through the end of the week, followed by increasing thunderstorm chances

02:07
WC 430PM TUES_Med Fire Folo_ajc_2026-06-30-16-44-32

Developer surveys fire damage at former Hudson River Psych Center, seeks tax relief to keep renovation project alive

03:02
WC_Firefighter_Heat_Safety10pmAJC_2025-06-23-22-24-10

Dangerous heat grips Hudson Valley as doctors urge residents to take precautions

01:56
blaise gwl swim

Warwick toddler’s heart transplant journey inspires Greenwood Lake swim fundraiser

00:14
Supreme Court

Supreme Court upholds birthright citizenship, rejecting Trump’s proposed limits

00:22
Pride Flag

Supreme Court upholds state laws banning transgender girls and women from school athletic teams

00:45
LD 3 HIGHLIGHTS.00 00 23 06.Still004

Felony charges filed as man accused of biting off part of person's ear in bar fight

01:31
blaise newburgh

New details emerge as police investigate violent weekend in Newburgh

01:58
6302026WCttt_2026-06-30-06-02-18

Local ties fuel astronaut Anil Menon's upcoming NASA launch

01:30
WC 430PM MON_Ben Pkg FIX_ajc_2026-06-29-17-03-42

Family and friends of Wappingers teen shot by police seek body-camera video, use-of-force policies

00:28
LD 3 HIGHLIGHTS.00 00 22 15.Still003

Weight loss drug coverage begins July 1 under new Medicaid pilot program

01:09
TallShips_2026-06-30-05-25-50

Tall ships from around the world set to arrive in New York Harbor for America’s 250th

01:30
WC 430PM MON_WC Heat Alert_ajc_2026-06-29-16-47-36

Westchester County takes steps to help residents beat the heat while celebrating Independence Day

01:52
Road Closure MS 062926_2026-06-29-17-05-38

Portion of Route 117 in Chappaqua closed until September for culvert replacement project

02:02
RTWCHVStonyPointOrganRecipientDiesDCaruso430pm_2026-06-29-16-57-19

Beloved Rockland County organ donor advocate Lauren Shields remembered for lifelong mission

02:03
WCHVWappingersFolo6298a_2026-06-29-08-09-10

Memorial grows for 17-year-old killed in police-involved shooting in Wappingers Falls

01:07
APJFK

JetBlue pilot reports hitting drone as plane approached JFK airport to land

00:58
WCHVRockland250Scam629_2026-06-29-12-22-55

Rockland officials warn of scammers selling fake ‘America 250’ merch

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices