Former prosecutor weighs in on tampering allegations against Orange County district attorney

Leaked state police documents accuse the Dave Hoovler of “tampering and interfering” with the investigation because of information he has about the murder from a now-deceased, former client from 2008, when he was a defense attorney.

Blaise Gomez

Feb 6, 2024, 10:50 PM

Updated 129 days ago

Share:

News 12 is taking a close look at stunning allegations that accuse the Orange County district attorney of interfering in the Megan McDonald case and is speaking with a former prosecutor about the new details unfolding in the public eye.
Leaked state police documents accuse Dave Hoovler of “tampering and interfering” with the investigation because of information he has about the murder from a now-deceased, former client from 2008, when he was a defense attorney.
“Attorney-client privilege is sacred,” says Rick Trunfio, a law professor at Syracuse University and former prosecutor. “It can never be revealed, even in death.”
Trunfio says despite the allegations, Hoovler’s conflict as district attorney didn’t exist until Holley was arrested last April – which is why he stepped down and turned the case over to a special prosecutor.
“District Attorney Hoovler was in almost an unprecedented situation in the sense that he represented somebody who may have been involved. This is what’s missing from this equation – a prosecutor has an ethical obligation to ensure the right person is charged.”
For the first time since Holley was charged, a law enforcement source with knowledge of the case tells News 12 that more than a dozen senior homicide prosecutors from across New York state reviewed the case before an arrest was made and said there wasn’t enough evidence.
The McDonald family feels differently and issued this scathing statement pointing fingers at Hoovler:
“Megan McDonald’s family says to David Hoovler: Enough with the fake outrage. YOU must STOP abusing victims and their families. YOU have chosen to hide your past. YOU are the one that ambushed Megan’s family days after an arrest YOU failed to show up for. YOU were surrounded by seven members of YOUR staff, and YOU changed your story in front of us multiple times. YOU cannot claim to be on Megan’s side as the DA and also represent Andre Thurston - Suspect #2.”
Trunfio says either way, the bickering may work in Holley’s favor.
“All this stuff that’s out there is just going to help him because it looks like this was so dysfunctional,” Trunfio says.
Hoovler denies that he tampered with the case and says he can’t comment further while the case is pending in court.


More from News 12
2:56
Sunny and mild Saturday for the Hudson Valley; mainly sunny Father's Day

Sunny and mild Saturday for the Hudson Valley; mainly sunny Father's Day

LIVE BLOG: News 12 weather updates

LIVE BLOG: News 12 weather updates

LIVE RADAR: Track today's storms

LIVE RADAR: Track today's storms

1:54
Thunderbolt 12: Checking out the road conditions in Yonkers

Thunderbolt 12: Checking out the road conditions in Yonkers

2:04
Village of Sleepy Hollow raises Pride flag for first time despite opposition from some residents

Village of Sleepy Hollow raises Pride flag for first time despite opposition from some residents

0:29
Carmel police warn people about recent car burglaries

Carmel police warn people about recent car burglaries

0:35
Prosecutors: Former Wallkill firefighter sentenced to prison for 2021 arson incident

Prosecutors: Former Wallkill firefighter sentenced to prison for 2021 arson incident

1:47
EXCLUSIVE: News 12 uncovers police data that shows 19 children struck by vehicles in Ramapo in 6 months

EXCLUSIVE: News 12 uncovers police data that shows 19 children struck by vehicles in Ramapo in 6 months

1:28
Officials: 7 people injured, 13 families displaced in Yonkers fire

Officials: 7 people injured, 13 families displaced in Yonkers fire

0:33
Dutchess County Sheriff's Office: Connecticut man killed in Town of Dover crash

Dutchess County Sheriff's Office: Connecticut man killed in Town of Dover crash

1:03
PARENTS: Dutchess County children lost for 2 hours on nightmare bus ride home

PARENTS: Dutchess County children lost for 2 hours on nightmare bus ride home

1:35
Orange County billiard player wins national championship, first competitor from Hudson Valley to do so in 30 years

Orange County billiard player wins national championship, first competitor from Hudson Valley to do so in 30 years

0:46
Police: 1 killed, 2 injured in East Fishkill collision involving garbage truck

Police: 1 killed, 2 injured in East Fishkill collision involving garbage truck

0:23
Democratic Westchester DA candidate Adeel Mirza drops out of race

Democratic Westchester DA candidate Adeel Mirza drops out of race

2:19
Caramoor Center for Music and the Arts provides summer entertainment in Katonah

Caramoor Center for Music and the Arts provides summer entertainment in Katonah

0:41
Weather On The Road: Matt Hammer visits New York Boulders stadium

Weather On The Road: Matt Hammer visits New York Boulders stadium

2:33
Food Truck Friday: The Patty Wagon from Freddy's Restaurant in Pleasantville

Food Truck Friday: The Patty Wagon from Freddy's Restaurant in Pleasantville

Is your dad awesome? Hudson Valley tell us why your dad rocks!

Is your dad awesome? Hudson Valley tell us why your dad rocks!

1:46
Parents: Suffern High School students suspended, banned from prom after livestock senior prank

Parents: Suffern High School students suspended, banned from prom after livestock senior prank

1:51
John Oliver delivers kitchen equipment to cake bear makers as next LWT episode nears

John Oliver delivers kitchen equipment to cake bear makers as next LWT episode nears