News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Sunny
54°
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

Jury zeros in on cellphone as deliberations in Ed Holley murder trial extend into next week

The jury of six men and six women sent six notes to the court Friday requesting to review specific evidence and testimony. They asked to see two short clips of a 2019 police interview with Holley, during which Megan McDonald's cellphone was mentioned.

Ben Nandy

•

Mar 6, 2026, 5:54 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The jury in the second murder trial of Edward Holley is focusing certain people and evidence as they finish their fifth full day of deliberations at the Orange County Courthouse.

The jury of six men and six women sent six notes to the court Friday requesting to review specific evidence and testimony.

They asked to see two short clips of a 2019 police interview with Holley, during which Megan McDonald's cellphone was mentioned.

Holley is accused of killing Megan in March 2003 in the Town of Wallkill.

Prosecutors have argued Holley was in the back seat of Megan's 1991 Mercury Sable sedan when he attacked Megan who was in the driver's seat, hitting her in the head and face with a hammer as the fight spilled outside.

Megan's body was found the next day by a dumpster on Bowser Road.

Her car was found three days later oddly parked at an apartment complex.

Her cellphone was left in the car.

An employee of a company hired by the prosecution to do low-match DNA analysis testified that Megan's cellphone had DNA on it that was 53 times more likely to match Holley's DNA than that of a random person, and that it was not a definitive full match.

The prosecution has said the finding is significant.

The defense disagreed, urging the jury during its closing argument not to put weight on the prosecution's evidence, adding that the prosecution's case is built on lies.

In the 2019 police interview, Holley said he was not sure if Megan had a cellphone in 2003 and would usually page her if she was not at home.

The jury requested late Friday to review more evidence, including another portion of the 2019 police interview.

The jury will return Monday morning to review the evidence and have some testimony read back to them before they continue with deliberations.

Top Stories

blaise new paltz

Hundreds of tires, lack of hydrants hindered battle against massive New Paltz inferno, officials say

01:42
HV STORMWATCH

STORM WATCH: Hudson Valley faces threat of heavy rain, gusty winds and travel disruptions from coastal storm

00:23
road rage

State police: Spring Valley man arrested following road rage incident involving a machete

00:22
1120bouncerrecall_2026-11-20-08-19-29

Baby bouncer sold on Amazon recalled for collapse, injury risk

00:31
CREDIT: Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger via AP

Newly released jury notes in Lindsay Clancy trial reveal dispute over reasonable doubt

00:24
1120toyotarecall_subclip_subclip_2026-11-20-07-23-36_05-17-05,04

More than 300K Toyota, Lexus vehicles recalled due to exploding airbag risk

00:29
TURKEYPIC

Turkey trouble? Call 1-800-Butterball for last-minute Thanksgiving help

01:20
LDV solar

PNW BOCES celebrates completion of major solar array in Yorktown Heights

00:54
DIANEXMAS_2026-11-20-00-19-35

Rockland garden center shares tips for decorating a meaningful holiday tree

00:44
RGNYONKERSHILLS11199P_2026-11-19-21-36-17

Mayor Spano wants to know: What’s Yonkers’ toughest hill?

01:35
melaniesuspectincourt_2026-11-19-16-34-32

Suffern man accused of recording people inside White Plains restaurant bathroom appears in court

00:45
RGNPORTCHESTERTURKEYDRIVE11199P_2026-11-19-21-36-36

Port Chester Carver Center distributes free Thanksgiving meals to more than 700 families

00:22
Screenshot 19-11-2026 131710 vod.prod.alticeustech.com

17-year-old Newburgh Free Academy student killed in Vails Gate house fire

01:04
blaiseduckfarmfirepkg1119_2026-11-19-16-48-55_16-33-35,19

Massive fire kills ducks and geese, destroys buildings at one of nation’s only two major foie gras producers

01:29
RGNAIRPLANERESCUE1119430P_2026-11-19-16-42-19

Respiratory therapist hailed as hero after helping revive passenger midflight

00:35
Screenshot 2026-11-19 164802

Second Middletown football coach resigns amid eligibility fallout

00:25
1119jpmorganchase_2026-11-19-16-45-59

JPMorgan Chase third-party services target of cyberattack

00:22
SEXUAL ABUSE ARREST MONITOR copy

DA: Mount Vernon man indicted for allegedly raping and sexually abusing a girl under 17

00:30
wildchaseplea1119_2026-11-19-16-54-13

NYC man pleads guilty after Saw Mill River Parkway police chase

01:54
blaise mdtn

Middletown head football coach resigns following playoff disqualification

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices