News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Monday marks 10 years since deadliest Metro-North accident

Officials said Ellen Brody, of Edgemont, got her car caught between the safety gates at the Commerce Street railroad crossing in Valhalla on Feb. 3, 2015.

Jade Nash

Feb 2, 2025, 11:52 AM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Monday will mark 10 years since an Edgemont woman and five others were killed in the deadliest accident in Metro-North history.

Officials said Ellen Brody, of Edgemont, got her car caught between the safety gates at the Commerce Street railroad crossing in Valhalla on Feb. 3, 2015.

She was killed moments later when a Metro-North train crashed into her on the railroad tracks.

Five people on the train also died when a third rail pierced the first car and caused a fire.

The NTSB found Brody responsible but cited a design flaw on that third rail.

In July, a jury found Metro-North primarily responsible for all six deaths.

However, Brody's husband, Alan, said he believes the company has failed to take true responsibility for the tragedy.

"They're taking us back to court to argue over those damages and I would imagine their idea is somehow another jury would disagree with the first jury and somehow found that they owe nothing," Brody said.

Officials from the MTA said they can't comment on the incident due to the ongoing appeals process.

However, they issued a statement saying, "safety is a core value of the MTA" and added that their teams have worked with various agencies on railroad crossing safety enhancements over the last decade.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:22
REtomworldcup410_2026-04-10-17-26-27

NJT CEO confirms FIFA-related Penn Station closures of NJ Transit

02:05
REperthamboychris410_2026-04-10-17-20-10

$10,000 reward for information that leads to arrest in Jewelry heist

02:19
Screenshot 2026-04-10 154811

Wonderful weather for the weekend and a pretty big warm-up next week

01:57
MURDOCHEBIKEPKG5pm_2026-04-10-17-25-06

Strict e-bike laws will soon be enforced. Are you ready for the changes?

newark bay

50-foot whale found dead in Newark Bay moved to NY Harbor as experts plan recovery and necropsy

NOLAN SCREENSHOT

Driver in fatal Toms River crash issued multiple summonses as investigation continues, prosecutor says

00:17
Gavel-1024x683

Sussex County man sentenced for attempting to sexually assault person he believed was a 14-year-old

Ganan Taza Blur

Hackensack man charged with distributing, possessing child sexual abuse material, prosecutors say

00:52
CherryBlossomsVST_2026-04-10-16-37-30

Cherry Blossom 10K returns to Branch Brook Park in Newark

fingerprint crime scene tape

Former Plainfield school employee charged with stealing more than $90K in payroll

AP26099110011792

Artemis II's grand moon finale is almost here with a Pacific splashdown to cap NASA's lunar comeback

Bayonne Hospital

Bayonne University Hospital achieves rare 24-month infection-free streak

01:45
REAmandafire49_2026-04-09-22-15-08

3-alarm fire in Ironbound section of Newark rips through warehouse

00:23
Pedestrian Struck Generic

72-year-old pedestrian struck and killed on Route 9 in Manalapan

Hackettstown 'Big Mistakes'

Dan Levy brings Hollywood to Hackettstown in new Netflix series

00:42
E-bike Helmets MS 121625_2025-12-16-17-12-08

E‑bike safety crackdown announced as Jersey Shore prepares for busy months

02:02
Thor

Paws and Pals: Thor is a fun-loving people-pleaser    

00:23
JeopardyGuyAM_2026-04-10-10-36-47

Lawrenceville native Jamie Ding chases Jeopardy history with 21st straight win

00:31
HelicopterStorySubAM_2026-04-10-10-04-42

Lawmakers push tougher sightseeing helicopter rules, commemorate Hudson River tragedy 

00:24
BigMistakesWatchPartyAM_2026-04-10-10-17-12

Edison hardware store gets Netflix spotlight with free watch party for Dan Levy series

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices