News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Poughkeepsie's crumbling Trolley Barn Gallery to close; art students displaced but programs continue

Staff said major problems have been discovered in the structure and foundation of the back part of the building, which stalled the project.

Ben Nandy

Dec 19, 2024, 5:28 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The grand expansion of a youth-led Poughkeepsie art gallery — that was supposed to help revitalize downtown and should be well underway by now — has been called off.

Instead, the gallery's landlord is selling the 150-year-old building that houses the gallery.

The Trolley Barn on Main Street appears to be in bad shape.

Arts nonprofit The Art Effect has rented the building the last four years from the housing agency, Hudson River Housing.

The front space of the building has already been in use as an art gallery and instructional area for up-and-coming artists. It includes "Senior Project," a collection of pieces by five local high school students who are about to begin college on arts scholarships.

That front space is fine, The Art Effect staff said. The unrenovated back space that was supposed to become an expansion of the gallery is the problem.

Staff said major problems have been discovered in the structure and foundation of the back part of the building, which stalled the project.

The Art Effect's executive director Nicole Fenichel-Hewitt recently learned Hudson River Housing is planning to sell off the building to either be renovated by someone else or torn down.

Either way, the Senior Project is the last exhibit at the Trolley Barn, but not the last one by The Art Effect's curatorial and event-planning students.

"Unfortunately, we weren't able to move forward with that project," Fenichel-Hewitt said, "but we are pivoting."

The programs at the Trolley Barn will be moved to other spaces the Art Effect still has nearby for other programs.

Students will also begin working on and showing their exhibits out in the community at parks and even sidewalks.

"We're continuing to work with the same number of youth," Fenichel-Hewitt said. "We're just doing that with the community as our canvas until we find our new future home."

The last day of the Senior Project exhibit at the Trolley Barn is Jan. 10. In a statement, Hudson River Housing blamed the decision to sell on "high maintenance costs" and the inability to secure the remaining redevelopment funding" for the $15-million project.

Fenichel-Hewitt said the Art Effect had been on pace to raise all necessary funds, with help from multiple state grants.

Those grants might be transferred to a future renovation project, she said.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:41
IMG 4844

Crews extinguish Sound Beach brush fire as all of Long Island remains under high risk

01:51
F P1 PM 1(149)

Chilly with patchy fog overnight on Long Island; much warmer weather is in sight

00:21
House Fire Generic

Suffolk officer treated for smoke inhalation after Huntington house fire

01:38
5PMJuliaMurderAquittalKK_2026-04-09-17-38-23

Nassau County man acquitted of murder after 30 years now suing the county

01:45
LI10JENNAFLOODS_2026-04-09-22-10-19

New York state offering to buy homes in certain flood areas of Mastic Beach

00:25
668751973 975577181478794 2753127999801039558 n

Firefighters rescue osprey entangled in fishing line

01:35
LI 5PM THURS_CouncilmanAssault_ajc_2026-04-09-17-07-00_17-01-03,29

Smithtown council clash turns violent, 1 member charged with assault

00:56
li5pmboljeremykidnapping_2026-04-07-18-25-17

Long Beach woman arrested after allegedly trying to snatch toddler out of stroller

00:24
5PMRooseveltConviction_2026-04-09-17-28-53

Roosevelt man convicted of murder in 2022 robbery behind Chuck E. Cheese in Hempstead

01:59
5PMCeciliaFBIHeuermannKK_2026-04-09-17-34-32

Confessed Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann to work with FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit

00:15
LI5PMVET103_2026-04-09-17-16-21

Nassau police hold birthday parade for 103-year-old WWII veteran

00:20
LIMEGAWINNER409_2026-04-09-06-15-23

$2M second-prize Mega Millions ticket sold in Deer Park

00:24
celtic222

Celtic Crossing in Kings Park closing months after liquor license was suspended

rex vics

Suffolk DA details how 'Gilgo Beach serial killer' Rex Heuermann lured his victims to their deaths

01:37
Screenshot 2026-04-09 171523

Matthew Morrison brings Bobby Darin to life in 'Just In Time'

02:47
LI 5PM WED_RexNuts&Bolts_ajc_2026-04-08-17-08-10

‘Sadistic, soulless, murderous monster.’ 'Gilgo Beach' serial killer Rex Heuermann pleads guilty to 8 killings on Long Island ending decadelong case

01:11
LI5PMMELANIE_2026-04-08-17-10-04

3 firefighters injured as 150 responders battle four‑alarm fire at Glen Head nursery

14:29
rex still

LIVE COVERAGE: Rex Heuermann pleads guilty to Gilgo Beach serial killings, admits responsibility to eighth slaying

00:26
LI 5PM WED_PolicePursuit_ajc_2026-04-08-17-17-03

Stolen vehicle chase ends with two arrests and troopers hurt across LI

00:22
burglary

Police offer reward to find 2 people who destroyed ATM in New Hyde Park burglary

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices