News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

Questions swirl after 3 men injured at New Windsor block party

Residents in a New Windsor development say they’re looking for answers after three men were injured in a mysterious incident while cleaning up from their community’s annual block party.

Blaise Gomez

Sep 8, 2025, 5:10 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Residents in a New Windsor development say they’re looking for answers after three men were injured in a mysterious incident while cleaning up from their community’s annual block party.

What neighbors described as a family-friendly gathering on Frank Street ended in chaos just before midnight Saturday.

“It was such a nice thing for the community to get together and have a good time and for it to end in such a tragedy, it’s just incredible,” said Mike Schaeffer, who works as a contractor in the development and knows one of the victims.

First responder radio transmissions from that night reported that the men were hurt after falling from the back of a pickup truck, but authorities have not confirmed that account.

Video from the scene shows residents upset — hugging and crying — as police put up yellow tape to block off the road.

Police returned to the neighborhood Monday, going door-to-door for information. They would only say three men were injured while cleaning up after the party, including one who suffered a serious head injury. Two others were treated for minor injuries and released.

“Injuries of any kind, it’s just heartbreaking,” said Jael Thoeny, of New Windsor.

People in the area say the uncertainty has been difficult.

“Being so many days later and not knowing what’s going on is just a little troubling,” said Schaeffer.

Neighbors say the block party was meant to bring people together — but instead left families shaken.

“We hope all of those injured heal — both emotionally and physically,” Thoeny said.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:11
IMG 4897

2 people arrested after 15-year-old boy fatally shot, 2 others critically injured at Eisenhower Park

02:15
Screenshot 2026-04-15 151253

Summer feel continues before changes arrive this weekend

01:54
LI 5PM WED_TrafficSentencing_ajc_2026-04-15-17-07-13_17-03-11,05

Sex trafficker sentenced to 22 years for crimes at former Sayville motel

01:29
5PMBodyFoundFix_2026-04-16-11-21-07

Woman’s body found in Long Island Sound off Lloyd Harbor identified as missing Oyster Bay woman

00:27
LI 10PM_EastMorichesCrash_ajc_2026-04-15-22-11-20

Man killed in single-vehicle East Moriches crash

00:32
MTLIGottiGrandson0414_2026-04-14-22-51-00

Gotti's grandson hasn't donated his kidney, as new lawyer apologizes for previous counsel's arguments

00:28
LIKIDNAPATTEMPT416_2026-04-16-05-14-09

Uniondale man arrested for trying to lure 11-year-old into nearby home

00:20
o

Teen e-bike rider critically hurt after being hit by minibus in Huntington

00:20
LIFAKERETURNS415_2026-04-15-05-08-34

2 BJ’s employees arrested for making $175K in fake returns

00:25
LIIDTHEFT416_2026-04-16-05-51-55

2 men wanted for stealing almost $9K from victim's account at 3 Nassau TD Banks

00:33
CHILD PORNOGRAPHY ARREST copy

Suffolk corrections officer accused of having child sexual abuse videos of kids

00:20
LICoramDumpTruck_2026-04-16-12-16-38

Two women seriously injured after colliding with dump truck in Coram

00:51
416taxingLI_2026-04-16-05-46-34

Town of Huntington increases fees at 2 golf courses

01:47
416liroadtrip_2026-04-16-06-27-35

Embark on an educational journey at the Museum of Disability History in Albertson

01:41
LI 10PM_ HuntingtonBessDetails_ajc_2026-04-15-22-19-22

'It's absurd.' Huntington residents react as officials mull moratorium on battery storage facilities

02:02
LI 10PM_SouthCountryBOE_ajc_2026-04-15-22-14-59_22-04-57,06

South Country schools likely won’t get state Special Act funding, needs to make more budget cuts

02:04
LIBALDWINFOUNDATION04155P_2026-04-15-18-27-59

Baldwin family turns to pickleball to fund breast cancer research

01:35
X Comet C2025

Rare comet visits our early morning sky this week

00:49
Isles Collapse MS 041526_2026-04-15-18-36-38

Islanders season ends with late collapse

02:16
Chris Wright

U.S. energy secretary addresses rising gas prices and tri‑state energy challenges in exclusive interview

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices