News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Showers
74°
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics

Baldwin teen sentenced to 20 years to life for deadly shooting outside Hempstead house party

Jacob McMillan, 19, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, attempted murder and weapons charges.

Julia Rosier

Aug 11, 2026, 5:45 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

It's 20 years to life behind bars for the Baldwin man who fired into a crowd as he fled a Hempstead house party, killing one person and injuring others.

Jacob McMillan, 19, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, attempted murder and weapons charges.

"That's what he deserves. He certainly doesn't deserve to get out after 20. He took this young girl's life for no reason," says Nassau District Attorney Anne Donnelly.

Prosecutors say he fired three shots during a fight at a house party in Hempstead last November.

One bullet went through the shoulder of another victim and struck 19-year-old Amira McCleod. McCleod was a student and basketball player at Monroe University.

Two other Nassau Community College students were injured.

The courtroom was packed with family, friends and teammates McCleod, many of them wearing blue and yellow. Many of them gave victim impact statements and speaking directly to McMillan.

"You ripped my heart out," said McCleod's mother Monique Baldwin in the courtroom. "I am lost without my daughter."

Baldwin said her and her daughter were like twins and her life hasn't been the same without her.

"I don't have the person that I can speak to or hold," Baldwin said after the sentencing. "She was perfect. She didn't cause problems. She made me a better mother."

"We were together all the time," says McCleod's friend Natalia Williams. "It's really sucks what happened, like just waking up to a text that your friend died."

"Her smile lit up a room," says Head Coach for Women's Basketball at Monroe University Damel Ling. "She was a leader from day one."

McMillan also tearfully spoke in the courtroom after the victim impact statements.

"I take accountability for all my actions," he said in the courtroom. "My intentions were never to hurt anyone."

McMillan's defense attorney says he hasn't spoken to McMillan yet but believes this is a fair sentence. He added McMillan's family was in court today and they were emotional as well.

More Stories

Top Stories

blaise door kick challenge

Dutchess County authorities warn of dangerous ‘door kick challenge’ incidents

01:01
HVF P1 AM 1 1

Pleasant start to the weekend with a Sunday rain chance

00:25
Luigi Mangione

Luigi Mangione pleads guilty to federal stalking charges in the killing of UnitedHealthcare CEO

01:49
814kat8am_2026-08-14-08-06-41

Employee accused of planting cameras in New York Athletic Club restrooms

01:47
814diankillamanjaro_2026-08-14-05-36-07

Rockland Hospital employee from New Jersey returns after wheelchair trek up Mount Kilimanjaro

00:00
TrumpInNassau

President Donald Trump speaks at the Nassau County Police Academy

01:44
814downtheshorenj_2026-08-14-05-25-58

Down the Shore: Enjoy sailing on the Navesink River

01:56
RTREGWCHVWrongfulArrestMPalmer9pm_2026-08-13-21-52-32

Lawsuit filed by 3 men who claim they were wrongfully arrested in Yonkers set to go to trial next month

01:46
RTWCHVDatingAppScamJGillis9pm_2026-08-13-22-03-43

Prosecutors: Yonkers man used dating apps to lure women to U.S. and rape them

01:04
blaise newburgh funeral

Final farewell for Newburgh detective who died at 35

00:25
beelinevosot0813_2026-08-13-16-19-23

Westchester officials propose expansion to student OMNY cards

00:32
RGNNewRideKK_2026-08-13-17-19-27

Ahoy, thrill-seekers! Playland Park’s newest ride Scorpios is making waves

01:41
RTREGWCHVGreenburghElevatorsOutLDValle4pm_2026-08-13-17-01-05

Tenants frustrated by recurring elevator problems at Greenburgh apartment building

01:43
8132026WCrt_2026-08-13-12-04-22

Road Trip Close To Home: Brewster tea room brings a taste of Britain to the Hudson Valley

00:23
Campers Electrocuted Fallsburg

Children from Brooklyn airlifted to burn center after contact with downed wire at Sullivan County camp

MIchelle Walker (002)

Rockland County fills human rights commissioner position with longtime public servant

00:26
OMAS PRIDE 1

Pet food brand recalls more than 600 bags of raw dog food over salmonella risk

00:49
Screenshot 2026-08-13 053808

West Haverstraw residents raise concerns over proposed warehouse project

01:29
8132026NJdts_2026-08-13-06-09-04

Down The Shore: Wall Stadium's high-speed racing action continues to thrill generations of race fans

OREO Twist, Lick, Vote Horizontal

Oreo is launching a chicken and waffles cookie; fans to decide if it comes back

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices