News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Mostly Cloudy
48°
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

East Fishkill Fire District denies requests for info about $1 million fire truck that was returned to manufacturer

Assemblyman AJ Beephan said he was asked by constituents, including some members of the fire district, to help find out how much the district received when they sold the truck back to the manufacturer.

Ben Nandy

•

Dec 16, 2024, 6:02 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The East Fishkill Fire District is facing increasing pressure to answer one question: How much taxpayer money might have been wasted over a $1 million fire truck that apparently never worked properly?

Leaders of the fire district are digging in, refusing to share details of a transaction involving taxpayer money.

Some government transparency experts believe the district is in the wrong.

"I think there were defects with the truck from Day 1," State Assemblyman AJ Beephan said of Truck 39-46, a 100-foot RMP apparatus that the district bought in 2014.

The initial purchase price for the custom-designed rig from Ferrara Fire Apparatus Inc. was $1,002,351.00, according to a bill of sale from early 2014.

Problems with the ladder and bucket collapsing without warning and problems with other parts of the truck persisted for years, Beephan said.

In 2020, after a long legal battle, the fire district sold the truck back to the manufacturer.

Beephan, a former East Fishkill firefighter, said he was asked by constituents, including multiple members of the fire district, to help find out how much the district received when they sold the truck back to the manufacturer.

Beephan sent the district a records request pursuant to New York's Freedom of Information Law (FOIL).

"We're just looking for that number, how much the vehicle was sold for," Beephan said during a Zoom interview Monday morning. "Taxpayers dollars were used to buy it and taxpayers have a right to know."

Beephan's request to know the price was denied.

The fire district's attorney, Christina Mazzarella, explained in her written response to Beephan.

"East Fishkill is unable to disclose ... receipt of funds received by Est Fishkill in connection with the settlement and the settlement agreement," she wrote, in part. "East Fishkill's position is that these items are protected from disclosure under §87(2)(b) and (c) of the law."

Those sections of the law state that record requests may be denied if disclosing the record would constitute an unwarranted invasion of privacy or if disclosing the record would impair any present or imminent awards.

Experts with the New York State Committee on Open Government wrote Monday morning in an email to Beephan that the fire district should release the information in accordance with the law.

"It is unclear on what grounds the East Fishkill Fire District believes an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy pursuant to POL § 87(2)(b) applies to the records in question," wrote committee fellow Miguel-Carlo Bautista. "The District itself does not have any 'privacy' rights as a government agency. Records reflecting the amount that the truck was sold for and to whom it was sold would not, in our view, constitute an unwarranted invasion of anyone’s personal privacy."

The fire district posted a response to Beephan's inquiries on social media attacking the Assemblyman, writing that he is "selectively and cynically choosing the information he is providing regarding this matter."

The post goes on to provide some details of the district's six-year protracted legal battle with the manufacturer, but does not disclose how much the district was paid when it returned the truck.

"We work hard, as I'm working right now," said town resident Joseph Rucci, in the midst of a food delivery. "We work really hard, and where our money goes is important to the voters, is important to the people."

"Somebody needs to step in," retired polive officer Richard Greene said. "This is our local fire department ... That's crazy. We want our money back, plain and simple."

Beephan said he will cite the committee's opinion when he appeals the fire district's decision in writing, and will send it along with several documents to the New York State Attorney General's office for review.

Beephan is also considering legal action on behalf of the constituents who asked him to help resolve the saga of the $1 million truck.

Top Stories

01:03
ARMONKCRASH_2026-11-15-12-32-49

1 child killed, 3 others critically injured in North Castle single-car crash

01:15
hv1

A sunny forecast & mid-November warmup in the Hudson Valley

APGroundStop11142026At10pmSG001

LIVE UPDATES: US air travel should normalize Sunday after ground stop triggers mass cancellations, FAA says

00:25
HOTELFIRE_2026-11-15-12-32-36

Harrison police block road as investigators probe fire in Purchase

00:27
1114whiteplainsstabbing_2026-11-14-07-23-19

Suspect caught after stabbing near popular White Plains shopping mall

01:35
blaise mdtn

Middletown football team out of championship after district withdraws court challenge

TURKEYPIC

Stop & Shop launches Thanksgiving meal deal with turkey, sides and pie for under $40

01:04
wchvrocklandhelp1113_2026-11-13-16-51-16

Rockland County groups send aid to victims of Brooklyn building collapse

01:53
Screenshot 2026-11-13 at 4.53.13 PM

Roadwork projects in Lewisboro and North Salem create traffic headaches for residents

00:30
image

Mount Vernon man indicted for attempted murder in stabbing of sanitation worker

01:00
blaise singer

Warwick teen Julia Roome lands coveted audition in front of ‘American Idol’ judges

00:31
Screenshot 2026-11-13 113506

Water-contaminated fuel, inadequate pre-flight inspection blamed for fatal I-684 plane crash

00:42
Screenshot 2026-11-13 053036

Mamdani cites New Rochelle Fire Department among 250 crews who responded to Brooklyn collapse

01:44
Screenshot 2026-11-13 122132

Police: Man stabbed in abdomen in White Plains; suspect fled on foot

01:18
1113HOTTOYS_2026-11-13-06-09-54

Hot Toys: Holiday shopping hacks

00:28
11132026space_2026-11-13-05-36-34

Local students show off hacking and coding skills using NASA data in Yonkers

00:00
Screenshot 2026-11-13 053724

Holiday magic returns to Yonkers with Santa, a tree lighting and a free electric train

01:11
Port Chester Water Main Break

Village of Port Chester has fourth water main break in less than a month

00:27
DRUG CHARGES MONITOR copy

Federal charges filed against 2 NYC men in connection with Westchester minor's fatal overdose

01:32
Yonkers Stew Leonard's Turkey Brigade

Yonkers high school students turn turkey donation into Thanksgiving meals for families in need

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices