EXCLUSIVE: Brian Britton’s surviving victim calls near-release of Dutchess County family killer a ‘fiasco’

Brian Britton’s surviving sister and the killer’s fiancée speak with News 12 for the first time – now that the Dutchess County man was denied parole after being just days away from release.

Blaise Gomez

Sep 14, 2023, 8:41 PM

Updated 276 days ago

Share:

News 12 is hearing from Brian Britton’s surviving sister and the killer’s fiancée for the first time – now that the Dutchess County man was denied parole after being just days away from release.
Britton killed his parents and 8-year-old brother in 1985. He recently almost became a free man for the first time in 34 years. Prosecutors say statements the Poughkeepsie killer made online seemingly victim-blaming and failing to show remorse plus chilling interviews he did with his fiancee about the murders seemingly sealed his fate with the Parole Board as a state prison inmate for another two years.
“The process worked,” says Dutchess County Chief Assistant District Attorney Matthew Weishaupt. “They denied parole based on what I believe is a very substantial foundation of evidence.”
Britton was initially granted parole for the first time since becoming eligible in 2013 during a de novo appeals hearing in March, but the board rescinded its decision after getting word of the social media postings with just days to spare. The board officially denied the 50-year-old parole this month.
His sister, Sherry Shafer, was a teenager at the time and was shot twice during the family massacre.
She issued a statement for the first time to News 12.
“I’m relieved after the fiasco the past nine months and am grateful to the district attorney for getting the board to see the true Brian,” said Shafer.
His fiancee, who goes by Heather Britton, called the decision on Facebook “corrupt and cruel” and said Brian Britton plans to appeal.
She denied News 12’s interview request but said Brian Britton would talk for “compensation.”
Weishaupt says Brian Britton’s behavior shows the Parole Board made the right decision.
“Somebody to this day who still lacks remorse and based on everything I’ve seen on social media, he remains a danger.”
Brian Britton will be eligible for parole in 2025. Weishaupt says he can’t appeal the current decision, despite his fiancee's remarks.
Brian Britton’s attorney has not returned News 12's repeated calls for comment.


More from News 12
1:52
Annual Juneteenth celebration draws crowds to Wolf's Lane Park in Pelham

Annual Juneteenth celebration draws crowds to Wolf's Lane Park in Pelham

2:02
Sunny, hot Monday kicks off scorching week in the Hudson Valley

Sunny, hot Monday kicks off scorching week in the Hudson Valley

0:28
​Poughkeepsie police: Man who pointed replica gun at officers disarmed, hospitalized

​Poughkeepsie police: Man who pointed replica gun at officers disarmed, hospitalized

2:09
Sleepy Hollow Sprint Triathlon raises money for youth summer program

Sleepy Hollow Sprint Triathlon raises money for youth summer program

0:21
Red Cross provides emergency assistance to 33 residents displaced by Yonkers fire

Red Cross provides emergency assistance to 33 residents displaced by Yonkers fire

1:50
Students sing their hearts out for the 2024 'Yonkers Idol' competition

Students sing their hearts out for the 2024 'Yonkers Idol' competition

2:02
 A potential heat wave is coming. These sunscreen tips can save your skin

A potential heat wave is coming. These sunscreen tips can save your skin

1:59
Revelers enjoy Juneteenth festival and parade in Yonkers

Revelers enjoy Juneteenth festival and parade in Yonkers

1:57
Rep. Bowman, Latimer encourage voters to cast ballots early

Rep. Bowman, Latimer encourage voters to cast ballots early

0:29
Police: 2 arrested for stabbing man in New Windsor

Police: 2 arrested for stabbing man in New Windsor

0:29
Saugerties man convicted of manslaughter for fatally beating man in 2022

Saugerties man convicted of manslaughter for fatally beating man in 2022

2:04
Village of Sleepy Hollow raises Pride flag for first time despite opposition from some residents

Village of Sleepy Hollow raises Pride flag for first time despite opposition from some residents

2:04
Kevin Jonas undergoes surgery to remove common skin cancer; urges fans to get checked

Kevin Jonas undergoes surgery to remove common skin cancer; urges fans to get checked

1:39
Showing support for Ukraine in the Hudson Valley during Yonkers Ukrainian Heritage Festival

Showing support for Ukraine in the Hudson Valley during Yonkers Ukrainian Heritage Festival

0:47
Westchester Medical Center pioneers robotic procedure to help those with severe hearing loss

Westchester Medical Center pioneers robotic procedure to help those with severe hearing loss

0:29
Carmel police warn people about recent car burglaries

Carmel police warn people about recent car burglaries

0:35
Prosecutors: Former Wallkill firefighter sentenced to prison for 2021 arson incident

Prosecutors: Former Wallkill firefighter sentenced to prison for 2021 arson incident

1:47
EXCLUSIVE: News 12 uncovers police data that shows 19 children struck by vehicles in Ramapo in 6 months

EXCLUSIVE: News 12 uncovers police data that shows 19 children struck by vehicles in Ramapo in 6 months

1:28
Officials: 7 people injured, 13 families displaced in Yonkers fire

Officials: 7 people injured, 13 families displaced in Yonkers fire

1:03
PARENTS: Dutchess County children lost for 2 hours on nightmare bus ride home

PARENTS: Dutchess County children lost for 2 hours on nightmare bus ride home