News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
FIFA World Cup

Long-awaited trial against Megan McDonald’s accused killer ready to begin

Megan McDonald’s alleged killer, Edward Holley, was arrested in 2023 – 20 years after the town of Wallkill murder.

Blaise Gomez

Feb 11, 2025, 5:13 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The high-profile murder case against a Wawayanda man accused of murdering his ex-girlfriend more than two decades ago took another important step toward the trial date on Tuesday, as attorneys for both sides hashed out several issues during a tense hearing in Orange County Court.

Megan McDonald’s alleged killer, Edward Holley, was arrested in 2023 – 20 years after the town of Wallkill murder.

As the trial nears, attorneys argued about whether some pieces of evidence can be used, and Judge Hyun Chin Kim denied the defense’s motion to dismiss the case altogether.

Holley’s attorney’s alleged that two special prosecutors assigned to the case at $300 an hour have been financially motivated to prosecute the long-time suspect.

Judge Kim disagreed.

The two sides also talked about if the defense can use an expert “memory science” professor at the trial to defend alleged discrepancies in Holley’s alibi over the years.

Kim did not immediately decide if that expert could be used.

Jury selection is set for March 3.

More Stories

Top Stories

00:23
Screenshot 2026-04-30 055833

Teen regains consciousness after late‑night pedestrian crash in Rockland County

02:11
P1

Cloudy with sprinkles today, then some sunshine this weekend in the Hudson Valley

01:53
blaise marcus burkes

Police-involved death of Marcus Burks ruled homicide, family and attorney say

01:52
4302026WCrt_2026-04-30-05-51-44

Road Trip Close To Home: Guided tour takes visitors underground inside Old Croton Aqueduct

02:30
Screenshot 2026-04-30 071955

Old‑school ticket rush as fans camp out for Foo Fighters pop‑up show at Starland Ballroom

00:35
blaise constantine

Middletown cold case killer’s sentencing delayed as co-defendants’ cases continue

01:40
0429josemedina_2026-04-29-22-08-02

Man accused of killing Loyola student from Yorktown pleads not guilty

01:38
WCBEACONSPOOL04295P_2026-04-29-17-38-13

Firefighters use saws and soap to free girl whose finger was stuck under water at pool

02:33
0429newrobridge_2026-04-29-22-16-30

Pedestrians have mixed reactions as new North Avenue Bridge opens in New Rochelle

00:31
blaise haverstraw fight

Gun-like device pointed at woman during fight with child nearby in Haverstraw

02:01
0429signaturelawsuitruling_2026-04-29-17-34-13

Judge rules Phillips‑Staley has enough valid signatures to stay on June primary ballot for US House race

01:49
WC_5PM_Rye Strangulation_ajc_2026-04-29-17-19-05

Rye Brook resident pleads not guilty in killing of 37-year-old woman

01:51
0429domesticviolenceinwc_2026-04-29-17-23-51

Nonprofit Hope's Door holds fundraiser to raise awareness about domestic violence

school generic (desks)

Technical glitches impact New York State testing for the second consecutive year

01:39
Schmigadoon

'Schmigadoon!' brings Golden Age musical magic to Broadway

00:27
4292026WCguy_2026-04-29-05-46-00

Grand jury charges man accused of killing Ellenville mother

02:17
BX5PMKINGCHARLES_2026-04-29-17-07-13

King Charles III and Queen Camilla begin New York trip by honoring victims at the 9/11 Memorial

00:20
4292026WCtwoguys_2026-04-29-08-46-41

Two men sentenced after shots fired at group of men in Orange County

00:40
4292026WCjudge_2026-04-29-08-46-09

Judge rules Democratic candidate can remain on ballot in June primary

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices