NY Legislature rejects Manhattan traffic fee plan

The state Assembly has rejected New YorkCity Mayor Michael Bloomberg's proposal to charge a fee to driveinto parts of Manhattan to curb traffic and pollution, killing theplan, Speaker Sheldon Silver said

News 12 Staff

Apr 7, 2008, 11:21 PM

Updated 5,922 days ago

Share:

The state Assembly has rejected New YorkCity Mayor Michael Bloomberg's proposal to charge a fee to driveinto parts of Manhattan to curb traffic and pollution, killing theplan, Speaker Sheldon Silver said Monday.
The survey of Democratic Assembly members in a privateconference comes after days of closed-door negotiations and meansthe city will forfeit $354 million in federal money forkick-starting the initiative. The Legislature faced a Mondaydeadline to act on Bloomberg's proposal, which was already endorsedby Democratic Gov. David Paterson, the Republican-led Senate andthe City Council.
Bloomberg spokesman Stu Loeser did not immediately comment.
The concept, known as congestion pricing, was proposed to cuttraffic and pollution by forcing more commuters onto mass transit.It would have charged most drivers $8 to drive below 60th Streetbetween 6 a.m. and 6 p.m. Monday through Friday. Truckers wouldhave paid $21.
It ran into strenuous objections from legislators from mostlythe outer boroughs and New York City suburbs, who said it wouldunfairly target commuters and their constituents.
"The conference has decided that they are not prepared to docongestion pricing," Silver said. "Many members just don'tbelieve in the concept. Many think this proposal is flawed."
"It will not be on the floor of the Assembly," he said. Therewas overwhelming opposition to the plan in private Democraticconference, but there was no public vote and individual lawmaker'svotes weren't recorded.
"You can speak to members of the conference," said Silver, whorepresents part of Manhattan. "If I were making the decisionalone, I might have made a different decision."
There was no immediate comment from Republican Senate MajorityLeader Joseph Bruno or Democratic Gov. David Paterson, whosupported the proposal.
Silver said part of the problem with the proposal, whichBloomberg had said could begin next year, is that it doesn'timmediately provide funding to the Metropolitan TransportationAuthority. He said the agency that runs the city's mass transit isalready underfunded and needs to be bolstered before it takes onmore commuters.
"That has to be the first job as we go forward," Silver said.
"The mayor is entitled to his vision," said WestchesterAssemblyman Richard Brodsky, a Democrat and leading critic of theplan. "And the Legislature is entitled to say it isn't in thepublic interest."
Brodsky also said the Bloomberg administration failed to addressall its concerns over a year, a claim the administration denies.Brodsky was on the congestion commission that held 21 publichearings, in addition to a City Council and Assembly hearing. The administration in Albany provided a list of 16 major changesto which Bloomberg agreed.
But Brodsky said fundamental, even philosophical questions werenever worked out. Among them, he said, was even the idea ofcharging people to use city streets.
City Council passes congestion pricing plan


More from News 12
1:32
‘Campbell Hell.’ Orange County couple say incessant dog barking from nearby kennel not being addressed

‘Campbell Hell.’ Orange County couple say incessant dog barking from nearby kennel not being addressed

1:49
Hot but low humidity today, thunderstorms possible Wednesday

Hot but low humidity today, thunderstorms possible Wednesday

1:40
Vote 2024: Primary day features heavyweight battle between Bowman and Latimer

Vote 2024: Primary day features heavyweight battle between Bowman and Latimer

1:44
Newly unveiled Rowley Family Pavilion health clinic to serve vulnerable residents in Middletown

Newly unveiled Rowley Family Pavilion health clinic to serve vulnerable residents in Middletown

0:28
Orange County DA: Port Jervis man pleads guilty to attempted rape of a child

Orange County DA: Port Jervis man pleads guilty to attempted rape of a child

0:46
Archdiocese: St. Mary’s Church in Yonkers merging with Parish of St. Peter-St. Denis

Archdiocese: St. Mary’s Church in Yonkers merging with Parish of St. Peter-St. Denis

7 Gorton High School students miss Algebra II Regents due to scheduling mix-up

7 Gorton High School students miss Algebra II Regents due to scheduling mix-up

Missing Connecticut teen found in Montgomery, suspect arrested

Missing Connecticut teen found in Montgomery, suspect arrested

South Blooming Grove leaders consider creating public safety department amid alleged disagreement with police chief

South Blooming Grove leaders consider creating public safety department amid alleged disagreement with police chief

0:47
Voting issues reported at Scarsdale polling sites

Voting issues reported at Scarsdale polling sites

2:38
Made in the Hudson Valley: Fleetwood Pastry Shop celebrates 27 years of serving sweets in Mount Vernon

Made in the Hudson Valley: Fleetwood Pastry Shop celebrates 27 years of serving sweets in Mount Vernon

0:26
Haverstraw police captain expected to be promoted to chief

Haverstraw police captain expected to be promoted to chief

1:18
Headlines: Cortlandt stabbing, LI man arrested for child abuse, West Nile virus detected

Headlines: Cortlandt stabbing, LI man arrested for child abuse, West Nile virus detected

0:23
Eastchester family escapes injury after tree branch punctures roof

Eastchester family escapes injury after tree branch punctures roof

0:23
Chipotle opens first NY restaurant with modern twist in Yorktown Heights

Chipotle opens first NY restaurant with modern twist in Yorktown Heights

0:35
Peekskill High School students gain real-world experience through 'Apprentismith' program

Peekskill High School students gain real-world experience through 'Apprentismith' program

1:14
Fallen tree destroys home in North Salem; homeowner ‘thankful’ to be alive

Fallen tree destroys home in North Salem; homeowner ‘thankful’ to be alive

1:07
Caught on camera: Intense storm downs trees in Chester

Caught on camera: Intense storm downs trees in Chester

0:28
Peekskill man faces felony assault charges connected to stabbing outside Cortlandt bar

Peekskill man faces felony assault charges connected to stabbing outside Cortlandt bar

1:44
Storms pummel northern Westchester, about 30 downed trees in Somers

Storms pummel northern Westchester, about 30 downed trees in Somers