Painting valued at nearly $30K mistakenly sold for $200 at Thornwood tag sale

A 25-by-30-inch oil painting called “Country Fair” was mistakenly sold at a tag sale in Thornwood last month.

News 12 Staff

Nov 13, 2019, 10:40 PM

Updated 1,627 days ago

Share:

A 25-by-30-inch oil painting called “Country Fair” was mistakenly sold at a tag sale in Thornwood last month.
Helen Giustino, 88, says she acquired the painting with her late husband from a flea market over 30 years ago.
“It was something my husband loved. It was a flea market, he loved flea markets, that was part of our entertainment through our years,” says Giustino.
The widow’s son sold the piece for a mere $200. Turns out it is valued at nearly $30,000. She says she is angry and emotional to know that the piece is gone.
The painting, which was featured in a 1947 Maxwell House ad, was scheduled to be auctioned off at the end of November.
Ronnan Clarke, owner of Clarke's Auction Gallery in Larchmont, intended to keep 10% of the sale and give the consignor, Dr. Sidney Hiller of Briarcliff, the rest.
Hiller says he plans to take the painting back from the auction house and pursue ownership. He declined to comment on whether he would return it to the original owner.
Giustino’s attorney, John Murtagh, says the family is prepared to take legal action.
“The right, ethical, equitable things to do would be let's everybody go back to square one, give Helen back the painting that means so much to her, we can give him back the $200 he paid for it and this is over and done,” says Murtagh.


More from News 12
1:24
Authorities: Newburgh fire displaces 18 residents, including 6 children

Authorities: Newburgh fire displaces 18 residents, including 6 children

1:52
Warm afternoon with a mix of sun and clouds in the Hudson Valley; scattered downpours this evening

Warm afternoon with a mix of sun and clouds in the Hudson Valley; scattered downpours this evening

0:33
Police: Home burglary reported in Mamaroneck

Police: Home burglary reported in Mamaroneck

0:26
Authorities: Fire breaks out at Lagrangeville car wash

Authorities: Fire breaks out at Lagrangeville car wash

1:57
Authorities: Fire destroys home in Spring Valley

Authorities: Fire destroys home in Spring Valley

0:43
Musica Y Mole Festival: White Plains High School celebrates Mexican culture

Musica Y Mole Festival: White Plains High School celebrates Mexican culture

1:02
Drug Takeback Day encourages Rockland residents to properly dispose of unused, expired medications

Drug Takeback Day encourages Rockland residents to properly dispose of unused, expired medications

2:02
'Gains For Brains' girls lacrosse tournament raises awareness, funds for pediatric brain cancer research

'Gains For Brains' girls lacrosse tournament raises awareness, funds for pediatric brain cancer research

0:31
Police seek public’s help locating missing 89-year-old man

Police seek public’s help locating missing 89-year-old man

Mathew Barzal scores in 2nd OT as Islanders beat Hurricanes 3-2 to avoid series sweep

Mathew Barzal scores in 2nd OT as Islanders beat Hurricanes 3-2 to avoid series sweep

0:33
Delta plane lands at JFK due to emergency slide falling off

Delta plane lands at JFK due to emergency slide falling off

2:28
Doctors are seeing an increase in pickleball-related injuries. Here how to avoid them

Doctors are seeing an increase in pickleball-related injuries. Here how to avoid them

1:23
Westchester commuters, residents weigh in on official congestion pricing rollout date

Westchester commuters, residents weigh in on official congestion pricing rollout date

0:20
City of White Plains to impose new speed limit of 25 mph, effective in May

City of White Plains to impose new speed limit of 25 mph, effective in May

0:41
Farm-to-table distillery brings boozy beverages to Goshen

Farm-to-table distillery brings boozy beverages to Goshen

0:22
Westchester County Center to host free prom attire giveaway this weekend

Westchester County Center to host free prom attire giveaway this weekend

0:35
Westchester Craft Beverage Trail takes residents on tour of 2 dozen distilleries

Westchester Craft Beverage Trail takes residents on tour of 2 dozen distilleries

Special teams carry Rangers to a Game 3 win and a 3-0 series lead on the Capitals

Special teams carry Rangers to a Game 3 win and a 3-0 series lead on the Capitals

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

0:52
Mother and daughter from Mount Vernon sentenced in pandemic-relief fraud scheme

Mother and daughter from Mount Vernon sentenced in pandemic-relief fraud scheme