HEAT ALERT

Heat blankets the region; heat advisory, air quality alert issued for the Hudson Valley

Plan to double size of Kiryas Joel under scrutiny over constitutionality of political district

A controversial plan to double the size of the Hassidic community of Kiryas Joel is under legal scrutiny as questions are raised about whether the deal is constitutional. Daniel Richmond, attorney

News 12 Staff

May 22, 2014, 3:11 AM

Updated 3,682 days ago

Share:

A controversial plan to double the size of the Hassidic community of Kiryas Joel is under legal scrutiny as questions are raised about whether the deal is constitutional.
Daniel Richmond, attorney for anti-annexation group United Monroe, says political districts that are defined by a particular religious group cannot be created under the U.S. Constitution. He says this is exactly what will happen if Kiryas Joel is allowed to double in size.
The growing population of more than 20,000 people in the Kiryas Joel community desperately needs more room. The concern raised by Richmond and United Monroe is that the community is exclusive to the Satmar Hassidic religious group, who historically vote in a block.
Richmond submitted a letter last week to the Town of Monroe, saying if the board voted "yes" to give Kiryas Joel 507 acres of land, it would be violating the First Amendment Establishment Clause of Separation of Church and State.
Monroe officials did not want to comment on the letter or about the constitutionality of the proposal, but town board member Dan Burke said, "For months United Monroe has been saying it is not about religion. Now it is about religion."
Kiryas Joel officials did not return News 12's calls for comment. The land deal is currently on hold during a state review.


More from News 12
2:00
HEAT ALERT: Heat advisory and air quality alert in effect through Thursday; cooler temperatures return for the weekend

HEAT ALERT: Heat advisory and air quality alert in effect through Thursday; cooler temperatures return for the weekend

0:27
State police: Person dead, another seriously injured in Woodbury crash

State police: Person dead, another seriously injured in Woodbury crash

0:29
Police search for suspect in stabbing incident of City of Newburgh resident

Police search for suspect in stabbing incident of City of Newburgh resident

2:07
Peekskill community mourns loss of caseworker who died after being assaulted on the job

Peekskill community mourns loss of caseworker who died after being assaulted on the job

1:40
Yonkers fire crews responded to a house fire during extreme heat on Wednesday

Yonkers fire crews responded to a house fire during extreme heat on Wednesday

1:42
Mount Vernon celebrates Juneteenth

Mount Vernon celebrates Juneteenth

1:40
Beating the heat: How residents are keeping cool

Beating the heat: How residents are keeping cool

1:45
Middletown woman’s family alleges mother of 7 died from withdrawal mismanagement at Orange County Jail

Middletown woman’s family alleges mother of 7 died from withdrawal mismanagement at Orange County Jail

0:42
Police report shows private school bus driver found at fault in Spring Valley accident that killed a 6-year-old girl

Police report shows private school bus driver found at fault in Spring Valley accident that killed a 6-year-old girl

1:33
Stony Point takes steps to help kids cool off with early opening of Splash Pad

Stony Point takes steps to help kids cool off with early opening of Splash Pad

1:50
Middletown celebrates end of slavery in midst of stretch of intense heat

Middletown celebrates end of slavery in midst of stretch of intense heat

2:46
‘People have worked so hard.’ Woman who helped make Juneteenth a national holiday visits New Jersey

‘People have worked so hard.’ Woman who helped make Juneteenth a national holiday visits New Jersey

1:07
DOT seeks input on I-84 freight parking locations

DOT seeks input on I-84 freight parking locations

0:28
Poughkeepsie Common Council unanimously opts into rent stabilization

Poughkeepsie Common Council unanimously opts into rent stabilization

2:35
Westchester County opens pools and beaches early as intense heat grips region

Westchester County opens pools and beaches early as intense heat grips region

0:55
Headlines: Woman stabbed in Newburgh, Peekskill homicide, driver injured as power lines fall on car

Headlines: Woman stabbed in Newburgh, Peekskill homicide, driver injured as power lines fall on car

0:53
Heat prompts graduation move for Orange-Ulster BOCES students

Heat prompts graduation move for Orange-Ulster BOCES students

0:20
Kingston road closure for new lane markings

Kingston road closure for new lane markings

0:28
Voters in 3 districts approve school budgets after earlier rejections

Voters in 3 districts approve school budgets after earlier rejections

0:46
Bedford police officers honored for saving family from house fire

Bedford police officers honored for saving family from house fire