News12 New York
Where to Watch
Download the App
Local News
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files

'The plea deals are the only path to resolution.' Daughter of 9/11 victim supports prison sentence for attackers

Elizabeth Miller was just 6 years old when her father, Douglas Miller, made the ultimate sacrifice as an FDNY firefighter.

News 12 Staff

Aug 21, 2023, 5:45 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

An Orange County woman who is the daughter of a 9/11 victim is supporting a proposed plea deal that would take the death penalty off the table for those behind the attack.

Elizabeth Miller was just 6 years old when her father, Douglas Miller, made the ultimate sacrifice as an FDNY firefighter.

Miller visited Guantanamo Bay three times over the past decade to attend hearings for the five 9/11 defendants imprisoned there. From her visits, Miller says she has concluded that "the military commission system is truly failing the victims' family members."

That's one reason why she and other children of 9/11 victims sent a letter to President Joe Biden last year advocating for a plea deal that could result in lengthy life sentences instead of the death penalty. Just last week, the Pentagon sent letters to family members of the victims asking for their input.

"The plea deals are the only path to any resolution in this case," says Miller.

She also supports the plea deal because if the death penalty is pursued, the defendants could appeal a conviction further drawing out the proceedings. In addition, she says the plea deal would also include a stipulation of facts and allow victims' family members an opportunity to ask the defendants questions.

"It will give us an opportunity to get the answers to the questions that I've been looking for, for over 22 years, and I think that speaks volumes for family members because with answers comes some healing," says Miller.

The prosecution of the five defendants has been delayed mainly because of legal issues surrounding the CIA's interrogation of the suspects.

"Because the country decided to torture these men, it took away any sense of justice I will ever get, and that is very frustrating to me," says Miller.

Miller says she understands that not all victims' family members agree with her stance but feels this is the closest to justice as she can get.

If a plea deal is approved, there's a law in place that would prevent the defendants transfer to U.S. soil. That means the Guantanamo prison would stay open indefinitely.

More Stories

Top Stories

shooting investigate image

Man arrested in Hillcrest barber shop shooting

04:24
HV TODAY

 Nice Saturday in the Hudson Valley before rain arrives Sunday

CREDIT: AP/HASSAN AMMAR

Iran reimposes restrictions on Strait of Hormuz, accusing US of violating deal to reopen it

03:58
duranteamcoverageCM_2026-04-17-22-07-03

Activists condemn decision to release ex-NYPD sergeant on bail in 2023 cooler-throwing death

01:51
MTWCFatalFire0417_2026-04-17-22-24-39

2 people dead after Lewisboro house fire

01:38
MTWCSewerLine0417_2026-04-17-22-26-41

Officials say progress being made in plans to fix broken sewer main in Hartsdale

01:27
0417springvalleyarrest_2026-04-17-17-29-54

2 arrested in connection with deadly Spring Valley shooting

01:42
0417bloominggrovefire_2026-04-17-17-35-00

New South Blooming Grove fire department told residents to call them — officials say don’t

00:29
0417newhampton_2026-04-17-17-36-55

$5,000 reward offered in search for missing New Hampton girl

01:49
0417amputee_2026-04-17-18-04-27

Beacon amputee filmmaker fights NY's ‘One Limb Per Lifetime’ health insurance rule

02:00
417wchvhealth_2026-04-17-11-31-50

Study: Small amounts of vigorous, short exercise may be more beneficial than longer workouts

00:56
417firerecruitments_2026-04-17-08-33-22

Fire departments to hold weekend recruitment drives across the Hudson Valley

00:22
4172026HVDRUGRINGTAKEDOWN_2026-04-17-05-31-37

Authorities bust New York drug ring that had operations in Westchester

00:25
4172026ROCKLANDSEXABUSE_2026-04-17-05-31-02

Rockland County man accused of sexually abusing child

00:31
4172026DUTCHESSEXPLOITATION_2026-04-17-05-30-35

FBI seeks additional victims linked to sex abuse case involving former Dutchess County teacher

01:41
0416brushfire_2026-04-16-17-22-37

Emergency crews respond to brushfire in the Town of Greenburgh

01:49
Image (5)

Car lands on Metro-North train track in Pleasantville

01:38
WCMAMARONECKAVERATS04165P_2026-04-16-17-58-54

Growing rat problem on Mamaroneck Avenue leaves locals demanding a solution

01:36
0416poughkeepsiebuilding_2026-04-16-18-14-29

Poughkeepsie officials investigate landlord, tenants organize, following building demolition

01:31
blaise vil florida

Worst Main Street in the Hudson Valley? Roadwork in Village of Florida sparks debate

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices