News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Celebrating America's 250th anniversary
Local News
Crime
Weather
Politics
Vote 2026: Hudson Valley primaries

Body of man found east of Tiana Beach in Hampton Bays

Southampton Town police say they received the call at around 2:45 p.m. for a body located near the beach. The remains were recovered in a bay-side marsh east of the beach.

Jenna Rae Gaertner

and

Brendan O'Leary

and

Roberto Torres

May 31, 2026, 10:10 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A man's body was recovered Sunday afternoon in a marsh east of Tiana Beach in Hampton Bays.

Southampton Town police say they received the call at around 2:45 p.m. for a body located near the beach. The remains were recovered in a bay-side marsh east of the beach.

Police identified the man as 38-year-old David Stetler, of Greenport.

The death appears to be non-criminal in nature, according to detectives.

John Lombardi, of Flanders, says he was the one who found the body. He was out scouting for horseshoe crab locations in a remote part of the bay that is only accessibly at low tide.

After wading through the marsh for more than 15 minutes, he saw what he thought was a mannequin. But as he got closer, he realized it was a body.

“I thought it was somebody lying on the ground with their face down, so I shouted, ‘Wake up. Wake up.’ But they didn’t move…” Lombardi said. “Then I realized it was a person who wasn’t alive. So I left and went immediately to the coast guard station….He looked like a typical person who wanted to go swimming in his underwear and t-shirt...and the body was blue.”

The medical examiner was set complete an examination as of Sunday night to determine a cause of death, according to police.

More Stories

Top Stories

01:38
0626beaconcliff_2026-06-26-17-17-10

Newburgh man dies after jumping from cliff into Fishkill Creek

01:54
F P2 PM 1

Sticky Friday finish before a split weekend for the Hudson Valley

01:50
blaise tuxedo road

Who pays? Tuxedo fire exposes $500K road dispute with state

01:59
0626flowerstore_2026-06-26-16-48-24

A fresh start: Pine Knoll Florist opens new store after devastating fire

00:36
0626edgemontbear_2026-06-26-16-37-08

Baby bear sighting near Edgemont schools prompts lockout

00:33
6262026OCTRACTORTRAILERFIRE_2026-06-26-06-24-48

Tractor-trailer engulfed in flames on I-84 in Orange County

00:22
0626injuredowl_2026-06-26-12-36-22

Injured owl rescued by local first responder

00:45
0626irvingtoncoyotes_2026-06-26-12-09-15

Coyote sightings near schools prompt warning in Irvington

00:24
AP26167097406696

Last-place Mets fire manager Carlos Mendoza, replacing him with Andy Green

02:07
blaise upk abuse

Highland mom says teacher shoved soap in son’s mouth at daycare as state moves to shut facility

00:31
Mets Service Dog

Meet Howie — the Mets’ newest teammate with a big future

01:56
Screenshot 2026-06-26 050640

Thunderbolt 12: Heavy rain causing flooding, downed trees across Hudson Valley

02:00
0625fishkilldatacenter_2026-06-25-16-43-07

East Fishkill to pass moratorium on data centers as developers float possibility of project in town

01:39
0625cortlandt250_2026-06-25-21-16-45

Town of Cortlandt marks America's 250th with Revolutionary War tribute

01:43
0625springvalleyhaitianstps_2026-06-25-16-50-58

Ruling on TPS for Haitian and Syrian migrants sparks concern among Spring Valley residents

00:25
Screenshot 2026-06-25 053522

Former prison dental assistant accused of bribery and drug smuggling in Otisville

01:26
Screenshot 2026-06-25 130822

Black bear sighting in White Plains neighborhood prompts safety reminder

00:29
Screenshot 2026-06-25 130803

New Siena poll shows Hochul widening lead in race for governor

00:46
BKSCOTUS62526_2026-06-25-12-49-49

Supreme Court allows Trump administration to end legal protections for Haitians, Syrians

00:44
6252026STURGEONINHUDSONRIVER_2026-06-25-05-52-54

Massive Atlantic sturgeon caught and released in Hudson River near Hyde Park

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices