Former discount shopping hotspot Playtog's Plaza to be reinvented

Business owners who have stuck it out at the plaza for years hoping for a revamp, are now dreaming big.

Ben Nandy

May 9, 2024, 10:20 PM

Updated 10 days ago

Share:

A crumbling shopping plaza – that was once a mecca for Orange County bargain shoppers – is about to get a huge makeover.
Business owners who have stuck it out at the plaza for years hoping for a revamp, are now dreaming big.
There is history in the plaza, which straddles the Middletown/Wallkill border on Dolson Avenue.
From 1959 well into the mid-1990s, people flocked to the plaza for deals at Playtogs and surrounding stores.
Playtogs and other local stores began shuttering as online shopping gained popularity and corporate retailers expanded.
"It was a pretty rundown plaza," Orlando Lallave, co-owner of Fusion Eyewear said, adding that about four years ago, it began to change.
Lallave said he relocated across the plaza two years ago to make room for a warehouse.
"I had the option to move out of the plaza at that point," he said, "but I had a feeling that things were going to change here."
Plaza owner Eric Jacobov said he recently secured agreements with Planet FItness to open a gym on one side of the plaza and another retailer he cannot publicly name yet on the other side, with more tenants to come.
Planet Fitness could begin its buildout as soon as next week, Jacobov said.
"I look forward to it," said JoAnne Walz, who works at the plaza and used to shop at the plaza during its heyday. "We had Carol's and we had Playtogs, and it's kind of where everybody was, but now that it's being revamped it'll be much, much nicer."
Work appears nearly finished on a speculative warehouse that is replacing the old building that housed the original Playtog's store.
Middletown officials said the warehouse developers are looking for tenants.


More from News 12
1:37
Police: 1 person dead in multivehicle crash on Sprain Brook Parkway

Police: 1 person dead in multivehicle crash on Sprain Brook Parkway

2:12
Warm temperatures with a mix of sun and clouds in the Hudson Valley

Warm temperatures with a mix of sun and clouds in the Hudson Valley

0:13
Dominican University in Orangeburg holds 70th annual commencement ceremony

Dominican University in Orangeburg holds 70th annual commencement ceremony

0:22
Police: Westchester patrol car struck by vehicle in Valhalla

Police: Westchester patrol car struck by vehicle in Valhalla

2:16
Israel music festival terror attack survivors share with New City congregation their Oct. 7 experience

Israel music festival terror attack survivors share with New City congregation their Oct. 7 experience

0:48
DEC says it's monitoring oil slick found at Village of Piermont creek

DEC says it's monitoring oil slick found at Village of Piermont creek

0:28
Yonkers police: 32-year-old man stabbed on Stanley Avenue

Yonkers police: 32-year-old man stabbed on Stanley Avenue

2:04
Rep. Mike Lawler launches bid for reelection in Haverstraw

Rep. Mike Lawler launches bid for reelection in Haverstraw

0:23
American flags torn down outside car dealership in Greenburgh

American flags torn down outside car dealership in Greenburgh

1:35
Gran Fondo World Championship brings cyclists through Rockland

Gran Fondo World Championship brings cyclists through Rockland

0:59
Period Project' - led by Yorktown student - helps raise $6,000+ for women in need

Period Project' - led by Yorktown student - helps raise $6,000+ for women in need

0:27
Officials warn against using gasoline to ignite indoor fires following incident at Croton-on-Hudson residence

Officials warn against using gasoline to ignite indoor fires following incident at Croton-on-Hudson residence

0:32
Hudson Valley veterans honored with flight to visit Washington DC

Hudson Valley veterans honored with flight to visit Washington DC

2:23
Candlelight vigil held in Mohegan Lake for missing Westchester teenage girls

Candlelight vigil held in Mohegan Lake for missing Westchester teenage girls

0:24
Police: 1 dead following multi-vehicle crash on Sprain Brook Parkway near Elmsford

Police: 1 dead following multi-vehicle crash on Sprain Brook Parkway near Elmsford

1:45
 Missed swim lessons due to COVID-19 may be contributing to rise in child drownings

Missed swim lessons due to COVID-19 may be contributing to rise in child drownings

1:39
New Rochelle's Haitian community commemorates Haitian Flag Day

New Rochelle's Haitian community commemorates Haitian Flag Day

1:21
Ardsley hosts inaugural Asian American Pacific Islander Festival

Ardsley hosts inaugural Asian American Pacific Islander Festival

0:17
Authorities: George Washington Bridge climber in custody

Authorities: George Washington Bridge climber in custody

0:49
Dozens protest proposed lithium-ion battery storage facility in Mahopac

Dozens protest proposed lithium-ion battery storage facility in Mahopac