Closing arguments heard in fragging trial

Closing arguments concluded Tuesday in the trial of the Army staff sergeant accused of killing two Hudson Valley soldiers in Iraq. The military prosecutor told the jury panel the only person with motive,

News 12 Staff

May 28, 2014, 6:54 PM

Updated 3,646 days ago

Share:

Closing arguments heard in fragging trial
Closing arguments concluded Tuesday in the trial of the Army staff sergeant accused of killing two Hudson Valley soldiers in Iraq.
The military prosecutor told the jury panel the only person with motive, means and an opportunity to detonate the Claymore mine that killed Capt. Philip Esposito, of Rockland, and 1st Lt. Louis Allen, of Orange, was Staff Sgt. Alberto Martinez.
The defense, however, insisted Martinez was in a port-o-potty at the time of the explosion, and the prosecution failed to produce any real evidence to prove otherwise.
In military trials, the prosecution has the opportunity to make a closing rebuttal to respond to points the defense made in its closing.
Prosecutors used the rebuttal to try to convince jurors Martinez hated Esposito for questioning his job performance in Iraq. They also insisted that the act of setting up a Claymore mine inside a room where Esposito and Allen were playing a board game was pre-meditated and planned out.
The defense struck down these arguments as circumstantial, claiming the evidence was selectively chosen to peg Martinez as the killer instead of exploring other suspects.
If convicted of pre-mediated murder, Martinez could face the death penalty. The military jury, however, also has the option of convicting the defendant on lesser charges.


More from News 12
2:28
Chappaqua, East Ramapo, and Newburgh reject school budgets; Clarkstown OKs 4% increase for schools

Chappaqua, East Ramapo, and Newburgh reject school budgets; Clarkstown OKs 4% increase for schools

2:16
STORM WATCH: Summerlike temps today, severe thunderstorms with hail possible Thursday

STORM WATCH: Summerlike temps today, severe thunderstorms with hail possible Thursday

RESULTS: News 12 Westchester/Hudson Valley School Vote 2024

RESULTS: News 12 Westchester/Hudson Valley School Vote 2024

0:40
Ramapo incident reports list tickets, charges against Monsey bus drivers who struck kids

Ramapo incident reports list tickets, charges against Monsey bus drivers who struck kids

1:10
Headlines: Woman steals $97,000 from business, health insurance fraud, Stony Point home invasion

Headlines: Woman steals $97,000 from business, health insurance fraud, Stony Point home invasion

0:30
Elmsford mayor censured by village board following harassment complaint

Elmsford mayor censured by village board following harassment complaint

0:33
Former State Assemblyman Robert Castelli dies at 74

Former State Assemblyman Robert Castelli dies at 74

2:06
Biden releasing 1 million barrels of gasoline from Northeast reserve in bid to lower prices at pump

Biden releasing 1 million barrels of gasoline from Northeast reserve in bid to lower prices at pump

2:31
36th Fleet Week kicks off in NYC with Salute to Ships at Fort Hamilton

36th Fleet Week kicks off in NYC with Salute to Ships at Fort Hamilton

1:31
What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's spring frittata

What's Cooking: Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace's spring frittata

2:42
Garden Guide: This is why you should grow Geraniums this summer

Garden Guide: This is why you should grow Geraniums this summer

1:18
Officials: At least 6 injured in multivehicle crash in Putnam County

Officials: At least 6 injured in multivehicle crash in Putnam County

1:54
New Rochelle students investigate 'crime scenes' for forensic class final exam

New Rochelle students investigate 'crime scenes' for forensic class final exam

1:23
Mount Vernon School Board meeting ends before it can start as teachers push for contract negotiations to speed up

Mount Vernon School Board meeting ends before it can start as teachers push for contract negotiations to speed up

1:44
2 preschoolers injured in fatal Sullivan County school bus crash

2 preschoolers injured in fatal Sullivan County school bus crash

0:36
Connecticut woman arrested for stealing from the Putnam business she worked for

Connecticut woman arrested for stealing from the Putnam business she worked for

1:41
Westchester lawmaker tracks down constituents owed money by NY state following Turn To Tara report

Westchester lawmaker tracks down constituents owed money by NY state following Turn To Tara report

1:35
Newburgh police commissioner announces sudden resignation weeks after chief resigned

Newburgh police commissioner announces sudden resignation weeks after chief resigned

0:49
Former medical officer manager from Orange County pleads guilty to health care fraud

Former medical officer manager from Orange County pleads guilty to health care fraud

0:35
New York State Police identify victim in fatal Sprain Brook Parkway crash

New York State Police identify victim in fatal Sprain Brook Parkway crash